Department of Psychology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina, USA.
Department of Medical Social Sciences, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2024 Aug 1;79(8). doi: 10.1093/geronb/gbae086.
Examining loneliness and social isolation during population-wide historical events may shed light on important theoretical questions about age differences, including whether these differences hold across different regions and the time course of the unfolding event. We used a systematic, preregistered approach of coordinated data analysis (CDA) of 4 studies (total N = 1,307; total observations = 18,492) that varied in design (intensive repeated-measures and cross-sectional), region, timing, and timescale during the first year of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic.
We harmonized our data sets to a common period within 2020-2021 and created a common set of variables. We used a combination of ordinary least squares regression and multilevel modeling to address the extent to which there was within- and between-person variation in the associations between social isolation and loneliness, and whether these associations varied as a function of age.
Within- and between-person effects of social interactions were negatively associated with loneliness in 1 study; in follow-up sensitivity analyses, these patterns held across early and later pandemic periods. Across all data sets, there was no evidence of age differences in the within-person or between-person associations of social interactions and loneliness.
Applying the CDA methodological framework allowed us to detect common and divergent patterns of social interactions and loneliness across samples, ages, regions, periods, and study designs.
在全人群历史事件中研究孤独感和社会隔离现象,可能有助于阐明关于年龄差异的重要理论问题,包括这些差异在不同地区和事件展开过程中的时间进程是否存在。我们采用了系统的、预先注册的协调数据分析(CDA)方法,对 4 项研究(总 N=1307;总观测数=18492)进行了综合分析,这些研究在设计(密集重复测量和横断面)、地区、时间和新冠疫情大流行第一年的时间尺度上存在差异。
我们将数据集协调到 2020-2021 年内的一个共同时期,并创建了一套共同的变量。我们采用普通最小二乘法回归和多层次模型相结合的方法,研究社会隔离和孤独感之间的关联中存在的个体内和个体间差异的程度,以及这些关联是否随年龄而变化。
1 项研究中,社会互动的个体内和个体间效应与孤独感呈负相关;在后续敏感性分析中,这些模式在疫情早期和后期均成立。在所有数据集上,社会互动和孤独感的个体内和个体间关联均无年龄差异的证据。
应用 CDA 方法框架使我们能够在样本、年龄、地区、时期和研究设计中检测社会互动和孤独感的共同和不同模式。