Kalinowski Jolaade, Hintz Elizabeth A, Izeogu Chigozirim
Department of Human Development and Family Sciences, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT, USA.
Department of Communication, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT, USA.
J Patient Exp. 2024 May 16;11:23743735241252475. doi: 10.1177/23743735241252475. eCollection 2024.
The SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic introduced many challenges and nuances that have transformed medical practice and research. The uncertainty caused by COVID-19 led to inevitable challenges to patient-provider relationships. The ever-changing landscape of COVID-19 research and policy proved to be challenging for the medical community and patients. These challenges also exacerbated long-standing issues regarding patient-provider communication and trust. On the other hand, these challenges gave voice to a burgeoning patient advocacy community. Through social media, advocacy and patient organizing, patients harnessed their power and organized over challenges relating to COVID-19 fears and concerns, ramifications of "Long COVID," and much more. During this unprecedented pandemic, there was a realization that the science and research surrounding COVID-19 is evolving and that there may be a benefit to embracing the dynamic nature of research and the scientific process. We propose that providers and the medical community should consider epistemological humility, which acknowledges insufficiencies related to the state of medical knowledge with a sense of understanding and respect for not having all of the answers. We argue that there is untapped potential in saying, "We don't know" and explaining why. There is an implicit culture that providers should be responsible for knowing everything and solving every problem. Epistemological humility challenges this culture, and inherently gives credence and voice to patient perspectives. We assert that epistemological humility is necessity when addressing contemporary health challenges such as COVID-19.
严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2,即新冠病毒)大流行带来了诸多挑战和细微差别,改变了医学实践和研究。新冠病毒造成的不确定性给医患关系带来了不可避免的挑战。事实证明,新冠病毒研究和政策不断变化的形势对医学界和患者来说都颇具挑战性。这些挑战还加剧了医患沟通和信任方面长期存在的问题。另一方面,这些挑战也让一个新兴的患者倡导群体发出了声音。通过社交媒体、倡导活动和患者组织,患者发挥自身力量,围绕新冠病毒恐惧和担忧、“长新冠”的影响等诸多问题进行了组织活动。在这场史无前例的大流行期间,人们认识到围绕新冠病毒的科学和研究在不断发展,接纳研究和科学过程的动态性质可能会带来益处。我们建议医疗服务提供者和医学界应考虑认识谦逊,即认识到医学知识现状存在不足,并以理解和尊重的态度承认并非知晓所有答案。我们认为,说出“我们不知道”并解释原因存在尚未挖掘的潜力。有一种隐含的文化观念认为,医疗服务提供者应该知晓一切并解决所有问题。认识谦逊对这种文化提出了挑战,并从本质上认可患者观点并让其发声。我们断言,在应对新冠病毒等当代健康挑战时,认识谦逊是必要的。