Benjamin Lizy Sonia, Pasay An Eddieson, Vijayalakshmi K, Alqarni Aida Sanad, Aseeri Abeer, Alsulami Amal, Gonzales Ferdinand, Mostoles Romeo, Maestrado Richard, Areola Benito, Gonzales Analita, Shanmugam Sumathi Robert
College of Nursing, King Khalid University, Abha City, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Nursing Administration, King Khalid University, Abha City, Saudi Arabia.
BMC Nurs. 2024 May 24;23(1):349. doi: 10.1186/s12912-024-02022-8.
Understanding the emotional intelligence (EI) and self-esteem of Indian and Saudi nursing students is important because their future nurse-patient relationships may be influenced by factors related to their unique cultural contexts. Hence, this study sought to investigate the EI and self-esteem of nursing students in Saudi Arabia and India.
A descriptive-comparative research design was used to compare 660 nursing students from Saudi Arabia and India who were enrolled in the study from September 2022 to January 2023. Nursing students were recruited from University A in Riyadh and University B in Abha, Saudi Arabia, and from University C in India.
The study found significant differences in EI scores based on year of study (p < .011), age (p < .024), residence (p < .005), and academic performance (p < .008). Students in later years, over 20 years old, from urban areas, and with good grades, had higher EI scores. Conversely, only age showed a significant difference in the self-esteem scores (p < .002). The year of study (p > .670), residence (p > .430), and academic performance (p > .526) did not significantly affect self-esteem. Finally, urban residence and good academic performance were significant predictors of EI (p < .005), while none of the demographics predicted self-esteem (p > .005).
Higher emotional intelligence among nursing students can be associated with several variables, such as being in the higher years of study, older age, residing in an urban area, and good academic performance, whereas self-esteem appears to be hardly affected by these indicators but probably influenced by other aspects that were not measured. This implies that educators in relation to self-esteem should know the relationship between emotional intelligence and nursing practice besides healthcare establishments; they need to enhance their teaching methods so that learners can have more resilient attitudes towards work, provide quality patient care, and promote a better learning environment for nurses who will become stronger professionally in the future.
了解印度和沙特护理专业学生的情商(EI)和自尊很重要,因为他们未来的护患关系可能会受到与他们独特文化背景相关因素的影响。因此,本研究旨在调查沙特阿拉伯和印度护理专业学生的EI和自尊。
采用描述性比较研究设计,对2022年9月至2023年1月参与该研究的660名来自沙特阿拉伯和印度的护理专业学生进行比较。护理专业学生分别从沙特阿拉伯利雅得的A大学、阿卜哈的B大学以及印度的C大学招募。
研究发现,基于学习年份(p <.011)、年龄(p <.024)、居住地(p <.005)和学业成绩(p <.008),EI得分存在显著差异。高年级、20岁以上、来自城市地区且成绩优异的学生EI得分更高。相反,只有年龄在自尊得分上显示出显著差异(p <.002)。学习年份(p >.670)、居住地(p >.430)和学业成绩(p >.526)对自尊没有显著影响。最后,城市居住和良好的学业成绩是EI的显著预测因素(p <.005),而没有任何人口统计学因素能预测自尊(p >.005)。
护理专业学生较高的情商可能与几个变量相关,如处于较高学习年级、年龄较大、居住在城市地区以及学业成绩良好,而自尊似乎几乎不受这些指标的影响,但可能受到其他未测量方面的影响。这意味着,除了医疗机构外,与自尊相关的教育工作者应该了解情商与护理实践之间的关系;他们需要改进教学方法,以便学习者能够对工作持有更坚韧的态度,提供优质的患者护理,并为未来将在专业上更强大的护士营造更好的学习环境。