Llopis Jorge Claudio, Haddaway Neal Robert, Omirbek Nurzhan, Simmons Blake Alexander, Garrett Rachael, Jones Julia Patricia Gordon
School of Natural Sciences, Bangor University, Bangor, UK.
Interdisciplinary Centre for Conservation Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Environ Evid. 2023;12(1):20. doi: 10.1186/s13750-023-00307-0. Epub 2023 Sep 26.
Forest conservation is a major global policy goal, due to the role forests play in climate change mitigation and biodiversity conservation. It is well recognized that the introduction of policies, whether aimed at forest conservation or with other objectives, has the potential to trigger unintended outcomes, such as displacement or leakage, which can undermine policy objectives. However, a set of outcomes that has escaped detailed scrutiny are anticipatory forest use behaviours, emerging when forest stakeholders anticipate policy implementation, deploying for example pre-emptive forest clearing, resulting in detrimental environmental outcomes. Lack of understanding of the extent and sectorial scope of these behaviours prevents us from devising strategies to address their potential detrimental consequences.
This protocol presents the methodology that will be followed to conduct a systematic map to identify, compile, review and describe the evidence available on anticipatory forest use behaviours in the context of policy introduction around the world. We will use two complementary search strategies, which we have tested before submitting this protocol. First, a systematic bibliographic search, and second, a citation chase approach. We will include articles based on a pre-defined set of criteria defined according to a Population, Intervention and Outcome (i.e. PIO) design. To support identification of knowledge gaps and clusters, we will report results of the systematic map in a narrative synthesis, an evidence atlas and other visualisations.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13750-023-00307-0.
由于森林在缓解气候变化和生物多样性保护中所起的作用,森林保护是一项主要的全球政策目标。人们普遍认识到,政策的出台,无论其旨在森林保护还是其他目标,都有可能引发意想不到的后果,如替代或泄漏,这可能会破坏政策目标。然而,有一组结果尚未得到详细审查,即预期森林利用行为,当森林利益相关者预期政策实施时就会出现,例如进行先发制人的森林砍伐,从而导致有害的环境后果。对这些行为的程度和部门范围缺乏了解,使我们无法制定应对其潜在有害后果的策略。
本方案介绍了将遵循的方法,以开展一项系统图谱研究,以识别、汇编、审查和描述世界各地在政策引入背景下有关预期森林利用行为的现有证据。我们将使用两种互补的搜索策略,这两种策略在提交本方案之前已经过测试。第一种是系统的文献检索,第二种是引文追踪法。我们将根据根据人群、干预措施和结果(即PIO)设计定义的一组预定义标准纳入文章。为了支持识别知识差距和聚类,我们将在叙述性综述、证据图谱和其他可视化中报告系统图谱的结果。
在线版本包含可在10.1186/s13750-023-00307-0获取的补充材料。