Hendel Emalie, MacEachern Kate Hill, Haxhiu Alma, Waruszynski Barbara T
Director General Military Personnel Research and Analysis, Department of National Defence (DND), Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Atlas Institute for Veterans and Families, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Front Sociol. 2024 May 13;9:1304075. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2024.1304075. eCollection 2024.
Canada's defence policy, , emphasizes the importance of leveraging Canada's diversity to strengthen the Canadian Armed Forces. Currently, women in the Canadian military are underrepresented across most elements and occupations, especially in the combat arms occupations, including among officers and non-commissioned personnel in combat units such as infantry, armored corps, artillery, and combat engineering. Research suggests that the benefits associated with the inclusion of women in combat arms occupations include an increase in collective intelligence, operational effectiveness, task cohesion, and diversity. This article explores the gender gap in the Canadian combat arms by examining the findings from two recent qualitative research studies on the perceptions of women in the Regular Force and Primary Reserve. The authors analyze female military personnel's perceptions of women serving in the combat arms, and the ways to increase their inclusion in the military. The key findings reveal the following themes on women's perceptions of servicewomen in the combat arms: great job for those who want it; challenging environment (e.g., working within a masculinized culture, necessary toughness, tokenism and the "pink list," being treated differently, and family loyalty); unique challenges faced by women in combat roles; combat takes a toll on women's mental and physical health; and benefits of women's participation in multinational operations. The discussion highlights the need to increase diversity, equity, and inclusion, promote a culture change that fosters greater inclusion of women in the combat arms, and increase operational effectiveness through training and policies.
加拿大的国防政策强调利用加拿大的多样性来加强加拿大武装部队的重要性。目前,加拿大军队中的女性在大多数部门和职业中代表性不足,尤其是在战斗兵种职业中,包括步兵、装甲兵、炮兵和战斗工程等战斗部队中的军官和士官。研究表明,让女性加入战斗兵种职业带来的好处包括集体智慧、作战效能、任务凝聚力和多样性的提升。本文通过审视最近两项关于正规部队和后备役部队中女性看法的定性研究结果,探讨加拿大战斗兵种中的性别差距。作者分析了女性军事人员对在战斗兵种中服役的女性的看法,以及增加她们在军队中代表性的方法。主要研究结果揭示了女性对战斗兵种中女性军人看法的以下主题:适合想要从事该职业的人;具有挑战性的环境(例如,在男性化文化中工作、必要的坚韧、象征主义和“粉红名单”、受到区别对待以及家庭忠诚);女性在战斗角色中面临的独特挑战;战斗对女性身心健康造成影响;以及女性参与多国行动的益处。讨论强调了增加多样性、公平性和包容性的必要性,推动文化变革以促进女性更多地融入战斗兵种,并通过培训和政策提高作战效能。