Honein-AbouHaidar Gladys, Bou-Karroum Lama, Parkinson Sarah E, Majed Rima, Salameh Sabine, Daher Najla, Hemadi Nour, Fouad Fouad M, El-Jardali Fadi
Hariri School of Nursing, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Faculty of Health Sciences, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Confl Health. 2024 May 31;18(Suppl 1):43. doi: 10.1186/s13031-024-00600-w.
The Lebanese government estimates the number of Syrian refugees to be 1.5 million, representing 25% of the population. Refugee healthcare services have been integrated into the existing Lebanese health system. This study aims to describe the integration of Syrian refugee health services into the Lebanese national health system from 2011 to 2022, amid an ongoing economic crisis since 2019 and the COVID-19 pandemic.
This paper employs a mixed-methods approach drawing upon different data sources including: 1- document review (policies, legislation, laws, etc.); 2- semi-structured interviews with policymakers, stakeholders, and health workers; 3- focus group discussions with patients from both host and refugee populations; and 4- health systems and care seeking indicators.
Although the demand for primary health care increased due to the Syrian refugee crisis, the provision of primary health care services was maintained. The infusion of international funding over time allowed primary health care centers to expand their resources to accommodate increased demand. The oversupply of physicians in Lebanon allowed the system to maintain a relatively high density of physicians even after the massive influx of refugees. The highly privatized, fragmented and expensive healthcare system has impeded Syrian refugees' access to secondary and tertiary healthcare services. The economic crisis further exacerbated limits on access for both the host and refugee populations and caused tension between the two populations. Our findings showed that the funds are not channeled through the government, fragmentation across multiple financing sources and reliance on international funding. Common medications and vaccines were available in the public system for both refugee and host communities and were reported to be affordable. The economic crisis hindered both communities' access to medications due to shortages and dramatic price increases.
Integrating refugees in national health systems is essential to achieve sustainable development goals, in particular universal health coverage. Although it can strengthen the capacity of national health systems, the integration of refugees in low-resource settings can be challenging due to existing health system arrangements (e.g., heavily privatized care, curative-oriented, high out-of-pocket, fragmentation across multiple financing sources, and system vulnerability to economic shocks).
黎巴嫩政府估计叙利亚难民人数为150万,占该国人口的25%。难民医疗服务已融入黎巴嫩现有的卫生系统。本研究旨在描述2011年至2022年期间叙利亚难民卫生服务融入黎巴嫩国家卫生系统的情况,这期间自2019年起持续存在经济危机且爆发了新冠疫情。
本文采用混合方法,利用不同的数据来源,包括:1. 文件审查(政策、立法、法律等);2. 对政策制定者、利益相关者和卫生工作者进行半结构化访谈;3. 与东道国和难民群体的患者进行焦点小组讨论;4. 卫生系统和就医指标。
尽管由于叙利亚难民危机,初级卫生保健需求增加,但初级卫生保健服务的提供得以维持。随着时间的推移,国际资金的注入使初级卫生保健中心能够扩充资源以满足增加的需求。黎巴嫩医生供应过剩,使得即便在难民大量涌入之后,该系统仍能维持相对较高的医生密度。高度私有化、分散且昂贵的医疗系统阻碍了叙利亚难民获得二级和三级医疗服务。经济危机进一步加剧了东道国和难民群体在就医方面的限制,并导致了这两个群体之间的紧张关系。我们的研究结果表明,资金并非通过政府渠道分配,存在多个资金来源分散以及依赖国际资金的情况。公共系统为难民和东道国社区提供了常用药物和疫苗,且据报告价格可承受。经济危机因药品短缺和大幅涨价,阻碍了两个群体获得药品。
将难民融入国家卫生系统对于实现可持续发展目标,特别是全民健康覆盖至关重要。尽管这可以增强国家卫生系统的能力,但由于现有的卫生系统安排(例如,高度私有化的医疗、以治疗为导向、高额自付费用、多个资金来源分散以及系统易受经济冲击影响),在资源匮乏地区将难民融入卫生系统可能具有挑战性。