Ambrose N S, Allan R N, Keighley M R, Burdon D W, Youngs D, Barnes P, Lennard-Jones J E
Dis Colon Rectum. 1985 Feb;28(2):81-5. doi: 10.1007/BF02552649.
We have undertaken a prospective randomized trial of one month's antimicrobial therapy for patients with symptomatic relapse of Crohn's disease. Criteria for entry included two major symptoms: fever, abdominal pain, diarrhea, weight loss, abdominal mass or complications (excluding perianal disease); and two hematologic abnormalities: hemoglobin, ESR, albumin, C reactive protein, iron, or total iron binding capacity. Patients were monitored for the aforementioned clinical and hematologic (hemoglobin, albumin, CRP) parameters over six weeks and for changes in fecal flora. Randomization was to four groups: metronidazole alone (M), cotrimoxazole alone (C), metronidazole and cotrimoxazole (C plus M), or double placebo (P). Seventy-two patients entered the study (18 = M, 16 = C, 21 = C plus M, 17 = P). After two weeks, improvement was reported as follows: M = 67 percent, C = 17 percent, C plus M = 71 percent, P = 35 percent. In the metronidazole group, two patients required surgery and one had troublesome side effects. In the cotrimoxazole group, two had side effects. In the combined group (C plus M), four had troublesome side effects and two of the placebo group (P) required operation. By four weeks, there was no difference in response among the groups: (M = 44 percent, C = 62 percent, C plus M = 57 percent, P = 41 percent). Antimicrobials had no effect on fecal flora or hematologic parameters. These results indicate that antimicrobials have little therapeutic potential for relapse of intestinal Crohn's disease.
我们对患有克罗恩病症状复发的患者进行了为期一个月的抗菌治疗前瞻性随机试验。入选标准包括两个主要症状:发热、腹痛、腹泻、体重减轻、腹部肿块或并发症(不包括肛周疾病);以及两项血液学异常:血红蛋白、红细胞沉降率、白蛋白、C反应蛋白、铁或总铁结合力。在六周内对患者的上述临床和血液学(血红蛋白、白蛋白、CRP)参数以及粪便菌群变化进行监测。随机分为四组:单独使用甲硝唑(M)、单独使用复方新诺明(C)、甲硝唑和复方新诺明联合使用(C加M)或双安慰剂(P)。72名患者进入研究(18名 = M,16名 = C,21名 = C加M,17名 = P)。两周后,报告的改善情况如下:M组 = 67%,C组 = 17%,C加M组 = 71%,P组 = 35%。在甲硝唑组,两名患者需要手术,一名有麻烦的副作用。在复方新诺明组,两名有副作用。在联合组(C加M),四名有麻烦的副作用,安慰剂组(P)的两名患者需要手术。到四周时,各组的反应没有差异:(M组 = 44%,C组 = 62%,C加M组 = 57%,P组 = 41%)。抗菌药物对粪便菌群或血液学参数没有影响。这些结果表明,抗菌药物对肠道克罗恩病复发的治疗潜力很小。