School of Medicine, Department of Paediatrics & Child Health, Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda.
School of Biomedical Sciences, Department of Anatomy, Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Jun 5;24(1):621. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05589-7.
The long case is used to assess medical students' proficiency in performing clinical tasks. As a formative assessment, the purpose is to offer feedback on performance, aiming to enhance and expedite clinical learning. The long case stands out as one of the primary formative assessment methods for clinical clerkship in low-resource settings but has received little attention in the literature.
To explore the experiences of medical students and faculty regarding the use of the Long Case Study as a formative assessment method at a tertiary care teaching hospital in a low-resource setting.
A qualitative study design was used. The study was conducted at Makerere University, a low-resource setting. The study participants were third- and fifth-year medical students as well as lecturers. Purposive sampling was utilized to recruit participants. Data collection comprised six Focus Group Discussions with students and five Key Informant Interviews with lecturers. The qualitative data were analyzed by inductive thematic analysis.
Three themes emerged from the study: ward placement, case presentation, and case assessment and feedback. The findings revealed that students conduct their long cases at patients' bedside within specific wards/units assigned for the entire clerkship. Effective supervision, feedback, and marks were highlighted as crucial practices that positively impact the learning process. However, challenges such as insufficient orientation to the long case, the super-specialization of the hospital wards, pressure to hunt for marks, and inadequate feedback practices were identified.
The long case offers students exposure to real patients in a clinical setting. However, in tertiary care teaching hospitals, it's crucial to ensure proper design and implementation of this practice to enable students' exposure to a variety of cases. Adequate and effective supervision and feedback create valuable opportunities for each learner to present cases and receive corrections.
长案例用于评估医学生执行临床任务的熟练程度。作为一种形成性评估,其目的是提供关于表现的反馈,旨在提高和加速临床学习。长案例是资源匮乏环境下临床实习的主要形成性评估方法之一,但在文献中却很少受到关注。
探索医学学生和教师在资源匮乏环境下的三级保健教学医院中使用长案例研究作为形成性评估方法的经验。
采用定性研究设计。该研究在资源匮乏的 Makerere 大学进行。研究参与者为三年级和五年级医学生以及讲师。采用目的抽样法招募参与者。数据收集包括与学生的六次焦点小组讨论和与讲师的五次关键知情人访谈。使用归纳主题分析对定性数据进行分析。
从研究中得出了三个主题:病房安置、案例呈现和案例评估和反馈。研究结果表明,学生在整个实习期间在特定病房/单元内的患者床边进行长案例。有效的监督、反馈和分数被强调为对学习过程产生积极影响的关键做法。然而,也发现了一些挑战,如对长案例的介绍不足、医院病房的专业化程度过高、为了寻找分数的压力以及反馈实践不足。
长案例为学生提供了在临床环境中接触真实患者的机会。然而,在三级保健教学医院中,确保这种实践的正确设计和实施至关重要,以使学生有机会接触各种病例。充分和有效的监督和反馈为每个学习者提供了展示病例和接受纠正的宝贵机会。