Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital and Trauma Center, University of California, San Francisco.
Department of Clinical Medicine, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
JAMA Netw Open. 2024 Jun 3;7(6):e2415576. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.15576.
Rifampin-resistant tuberculosis treatment regimens require electrocardiographic (ECG) monitoring due to the use of multiple QTc-prolonging agents. Formal 12-lead ECG devices represent a significant burden in resource-constrained clinics worldwide and a potential barrier to treatment scale-up in some settings.
To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of a handheld 6-lead ECG device within resource-constrained clinics.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This diagnostic study was performed within a multicenter, pragmatic (broad eligibility criteria with no exclusions for randomized participants), phase 3 rifampin-resistant tuberculosis treatment trial (BEAT Tuberculosis [Building Evidence for Advancing New Treatment for Tuberculosis]) in South Africa. A total of 192 consecutive trial participants were assessed, and 191 were recruited for this substudy between January 21, 2021, and March 27, 2023. A low proportion (3 of 432 [0.7%]) of all screened trial participants were excluded due to a QTc interval greater than 450 milliseconds. Triplicate reference standard 12-lead ECG results were human calibrated with readers blinded to 6-lead ECG results.
Diagnostic accuracy, repeatability, and feasibility of a 6-lead ECG device.
A total of 191 participants (median age, 36 years [IQR, 28-45 years]; 81 female participants [42.4%]; 91 participants [47.6%] living with HIV) with a median of 4 clinic visits (IQR, 3-4 visits) contributed 2070 and 2015 12-lead and 6-lead ECG assessments, respectively. Across 170 participants attending 489 total clinic visits where valid triplicate QTc measurements were available for both devices, the mean 12-lead QTc measurement was 418 milliseconds (range, 321-519 milliseconds), and the mean 6-lead QTc measurement was 422 milliseconds (range, 288-574 milliseconds; proportion of variation explained, R2 = 0.4; P < .001). At a QTc interval threshold of 500 milliseconds, the 6-lead ECG device had a negative predictive value of 99.8% (95% CI, 98.8%-99.9%) and a positive predictive value of 16.7% (95% CI, 0.4%-64.1%). The normal expected range of within-individual variability of the 6-lead ECG device was high (±50.2 milliseconds [coefficient of variation, 6.0%]) relative to the 12-lead ECG device (±22.0 milliseconds [coefficient of variation, 2.7%]). The mean (SD) increase in the 12-lead QTc measurement during treatment was 10.1 (25.8) milliseconds, with 0.8% of clinic visits (4 of 489) having a QTc interval of 500 milliseconds or more.
This study suggests that simplified, handheld 6-lead ECG devices are effective triage tests that could reduce the need to perform 12-lead ECG monitoring in resource-constrained settings.
由于使用了多种 QTc 延长剂,利福平耐药结核病的治疗方案需要进行心电图 (ECG) 监测。在全球资源有限的诊所中,使用正式的 12 导联 ECG 设备会带来很大的负担,并且在某些情况下可能会成为治疗扩大规模的障碍。
评估在资源有限的诊所中使用手持式 6 导联 ECG 设备的诊断准确性。
设计、地点和参与者:这项诊断研究是在南非进行的一项多中心、实用(广泛的纳入标准,对随机参与者没有排除)、利福平耐药结核病治疗试验(BEAT 结核病 [建立证据以推进新的结核病治疗])中进行的。共有 192 名连续试验参与者接受了评估,其中 191 名参与者于 2021 年 1 月 21 日至 2023 年 3 月 27 日期间入组了这项亚研究。由于 QTc 间隔大于 450 毫秒,所有筛查试验参与者中有 3 名(432 名中的 0.7%)比例较低而被排除在外。参考标准 12 导联 ECG 结果进行了三次重复测量,读数者对 6 导联 ECG 结果进行了盲法评估。
6 导联 ECG 设备的诊断准确性、可重复性和可行性。
共有 191 名参与者(中位数年龄,36 岁[IQR,28-45 岁];81 名女性参与者[42.4%];91 名参与者[47.6%]患有 HIV),中位数就诊 4 次(IQR,3-4 次就诊),分别贡献了 2070 次和 2015 次 12 导联和 6 导联 ECG 评估。在 170 名参与者参加的 489 次总就诊中,有 489 次就诊中两种设备都有有效的三重复测量 QTc 值,12 导联 QTc 测量值的平均值为 418 毫秒(范围,321-519 毫秒),6 导联 QTc 测量值的平均值为 422 毫秒(范围,288-574 毫秒;解释比例,R2=0.4;P<0.001)。在 QTc 间隔阈值为 500 毫秒时,6 导联 ECG 设备的阴性预测值为 99.8%(95%CI,98.8%-99.9%),阳性预测值为 16.7%(95%CI,0.4%-64.1%)。6 导联 ECG 设备的个体内变异性正常预期范围较高(±50.2 毫秒[变异系数,6.0%]),而 12 导联 ECG 设备的变异性正常预期范围较低(±22.0 毫秒[变异系数,2.7%])。治疗期间 12 导联 QTc 测量值的平均(SD)增加为 10.1(25.8)毫秒,489 次就诊中有 0.8%(4 次就诊)的 QTc 间隔为 500 毫秒或更长。
这项研究表明,简化的手持式 6 导联 ECG 设备是有效的分诊测试,可以减少在资源有限的环境中进行 12 导联 ECG 监测的需求。