Kyte Sarah Blanchard, Riegle-Crumb Catherine
Education & Employment Research Center, Rutgers University, 94 Rockafeller Road, Second Floor, Piscataway, NJ 00854-8054, USA.
Population Research Center, The University of Texas at Austin, 305 E. 23rd Street, Stop G1800, Austin, TX 78712-1699, USA.
Soc Sci. 2017 Mar;6(1). doi: 10.3390/socsci6010019. Epub 2017 Feb 21.
Despite efforts to increase participation in science, technology, engineering and math fields (STEM), the role of students' perceptions of the social relevance of science in guiding their expectations to major in STEM remains largely unexplored. Though science education scholars predict that perceptions of social relevance likely matter equally for boys and girls, gender scholars suggest that these perceptions should matter more for girls than boys. Using longitudinal data from a large, urban, low-income, and predominantly minority-serving district, this study examines the potentially gendered role of perceptions of social relevance in ninth graders' expectations to major in STEM. Further, it examines these dynamics with respect to expectations to major in any STEM field as well as expectations to major in specific STEM fields. Findings largely support the perspective of gender scholars; perceptions of the social relevance of science positively and significantly predict female, but not male, students' intentions to major in STEM (vs. non-STEM fields). Subsequent analyses that look at intentions to major in specific STEM fields reveal a similar pattern, such that perceptions of relevance positively predict female students' intentions to major in the biological sciences, the physical sciences, and engineering, while male students' intentions are not similarly impacted. By contrast, positive perceptions of the relevance of science predict a modest increase in interest in computer science for both boys and girls.
尽管人们努力提高对科学、技术、工程和数学领域(STEM)的参与度,但学生对科学社会相关性的认知在引导他们选择STEM专业方面所起的作用在很大程度上仍未得到探索。虽然科学教育学者预测,社会相关性认知对男孩和女孩可能同样重要,但性别研究学者认为,这些认知对女孩的重要性应高于男孩。本研究利用来自一个大型城市、低收入且主要服务少数族裔地区的纵向数据,考察了社会相关性认知在九年级学生选择STEM专业期望中可能存在的性别差异作用。此外,研究还考察了在选择任何STEM领域专业的期望以及选择特定STEM领域专业的期望方面的这些动态变化。研究结果在很大程度上支持了性别研究学者的观点;对科学社会相关性的认知积极且显著地预测了女生而非男生选择STEM专业(相对于非STEM专业)的意愿。随后针对选择特定STEM领域专业意愿的分析揭示了类似的模式,即相关性认知积极地预测了女生选择生物科学、物理科学和工程专业的意愿,而男生的意愿并未受到类似影响。相比之下,对科学相关性的积极认知预测了男孩和女孩对计算机科学兴趣的适度增加。