Bhatt Fenil R, Orosz Lindsay D, Schuler Kirsten A, Allen Brandon J, Roy Rita T, Grigorian Julia N, Schuler Thomas C, Good Christopher R, Jazini Ehsan, Haines Colin M
Department of Surgery, Virginia Spine Institute, Reston, VA, USA.
Research Department, National Spine Health Foundation, Reston, VA, USA.
J Spine Surg. 2024 Jun 21;10(2):165-176. doi: 10.21037/jss-23-135. Epub 2024 May 21.
BACKGROUND: Traditional surgical treatment for symptomatic cervical degenerative disc disease is anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF), yet the increased risk of adjacent segment degeneration (ASD) requiring additional surgery exists and may result in limiting long-term surgical success when it occurs. Disc arthroplasty can preserve or restore physiologic range of motion (ROM), decreasing adjacent level stress and subsequent surgery. For patients with multilevel pathology requiring at least a 1-level fusion, interest is growing in anterior cervical hybrid (ACH) surgery as a partial motion-preserving procedure to decrease the adjacent level burden. This radiographic study compares postoperative superior adjacent segment motion between ACH and ACDF. Secondarily, total global motion, construct motion, inferior adjacent segment motion, and sagittal alignment parameters were compared. METHODS: This is a single-center, multi-surgeon, retrospective cohort study of 2- and 3-level ACH and ACDF cases between 2013 and 2021. Degrees of motion were analyzed on flexion/extension views using Cobb angles to measure global (C2-C7) construct and adjacent segment lordosis. Neutral lateral X-rays were analyzed for alignment parameters, including global lordosis, cervical sagittal vertical axis (cSVA), and T1 slope (T1S). Differences were determined by independent t-test and Fisher's exact test. RESULTS: Of 100 patients, 38% were 2-level cases (47% ACH, 53% ACDF) and 62% were 3-level cases: (52% ACH, 48% ACDF). Postoperatively, superior adjacent segment motion increased with ACDF and decreased with ACH (-1.3°±5.3° ACH, 1.6°±4.6° ACDF, P=0.005). Postoperatively, the ACH group had greater ROM across the construct (16.3°±8.7° ACH, 4.7°±3.3° ACDF, P<0.001) and total global ROM (38.0°±12.8° ACH, 28.0°±11.1° ACDF, P<0.001). ACH resulted in a significant reduction of motion loss across the construct (-10.0°±11.7° ACH, -18.1°±10.8° ACDF, P<0.001). Postoperative alignment restoration was similar between both cohorts (-2.61°±8.36° ACH, 0.04°±12.24° ACDF, P=0.21). CONCLUSIONS: Compared to ACDF, hybrid constructs partially preserved motion across operative levels and had greater postoperative global ROM without increasing superior adjacent segment mobility or sacrificing alignment restoration. This supports the consideration of ACH in patients with multilevel degenerative cervical pathology requiring at least a 1-level fusion and suggests a propensity for long-term success by reducing the superior adjacent segment burden.
背景:有症状的颈椎间盘退变疾病的传统手术治疗方法是颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术(ACDF),然而存在相邻节段退变(ASD)风险增加并需要额外手术的情况,一旦发生可能会限制长期手术成功率。椎间盘置换术可以保留或恢复生理活动范围(ROM),减轻相邻节段应力及后续手术需求。对于需要至少一个节段融合的多节段病变患者,颈椎前路混合手术(ACH)作为一种部分保留运动的手术以减轻相邻节段负担,其关注度日益增加。本影像学研究比较了ACH和ACDF术后上位相邻节段的活动情况。其次,还比较了整体总活动度、植入物活动度、下位相邻节段活动度和矢状面排列参数。 方法:这是一项单中心、多外科医生的回顾性队列研究,纳入了2013年至2021年间接受2节段和3节段ACH及ACDF手术的病例。使用Cobb角在屈伸位X线片上分析活动度,以测量整体(C2-C7)植入物和相邻节段的前凸。对中立位侧位X线片分析排列参数,包括整体前凸、颈椎矢状垂直轴(cSVA)和T1斜率(T1S)。差异通过独立t检验和Fisher精确检验确定。 结果:100例患者中,38%为2节段病例(47%为ACH,53%为ACDF),62%为3节段病例(52%为ACH,48%为ACDF)。术后,ACDF组上位相邻节段活动度增加,ACH组则降低(ACH为-1.3°±5.3°,ACDF为1.6°±4.6°,P=0.005)。术后,ACH组在植入物上的活动度更大(ACH为16.3°±8.7°,ACDF为4.7°±3.3°,P<0.001),整体总活动度也更大(ACH为38.0°±12.8°,ACDF为28.0°±11.1°,P<0.001)。ACH导致植入物上的活动度损失显著减少(ACH为-10.0°±11.7°,ACDF为-18.1°±10.8°,P<0.001)。两组术后排列恢复情况相似(ACH为-2.61°±8.36°,ACDF为0.04°±12.24°,P= 0.21)。 结论:与ACDF相比,混合植入物部分保留了手术节段的活动度,术后整体总活动度更大,且未增加上位相邻节段的活动度,也未牺牲排列恢复。这支持了对于需要至少一个节段融合的多节段颈椎退变病变患者考虑采用ACH手术,并提示通过减轻上位相邻节段负担可能获得长期成功。
J Neurosurg Spine. 2017-5
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2009-5-15
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2023-3-14
J Craniovertebr Junction Spine. 2021