Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Tokai University School of Medicine, Isehara, Kanagawa, Japan.
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Tokai University Hachioji Hospital, 1838 Ishikawa-machi, Hachioji, Hachioji, Tokyo, 192-0032, Japan.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2024 Oct;281(10):5527-5533. doi: 10.1007/s00405-024-08785-9. Epub 2024 Jul 8.
This study aimed to assess reliable options for bedside diagnosis of silent aspiration in the intensive care unit by examining the use of default grayscale images (DGI) obtained using a mobile, general-purpose, radiography system capable of dynamic digital radiography (M-DDR) and inverted grayscale images (IGI) of DGI.
This cohort study (exploratory and preliminary) involved 18 adult patients (mean age, 89.0 years) for whom a swallowing assessment request was received from their primary physicians. Fifty-six IGI videoclips were evaluated by three specialists using the penetration-aspiration scale (PAS), with the gold standard being the consensus reading of all three specialists. Another three speech-language pathologists (SLPs) assessed 56 DGI and IGI videoclips using the PAS. PAS scores 1 and 2 were classified as normal range, PAS scores 3-5 as pathological laryngeal penetration, and PAS scores 6-8 as aspiration. The correct rates with IGI and DGI were then determined, and the level of agreement of IGI and DGI evaluations was evaluated.
The correct rate of all evaluators was 100% for normal range, 80-100% for pathological laryngeal penetration, and 83-100% for aspiration with IGI and 100% for normal range, 90% for pathological laryngeal penetration, and 83% for aspiration with DGI. The kappa coefficient for IGI and DGI showed almost complete agreement for abnormal conditions.
Dynamic imaging of swallowing 2-5 ml of liquid using M-DDR performed for elderly patients at the bedside showed that aspiration assessments by SLPs obtained from DGI videos immediately after imaging are acceptable.
本研究旨在通过检查使用移动通用射线照相系统(M-DDR)获取的默认灰度图像(DGI)和 DGI 的倒置灰度图像(IGI),评估床边诊断 ICU 中无症状性误吸的可靠选择。
这项队列研究(探索性和初步研究)纳入了 18 名成年患者(平均年龄 89.0 岁),他们的主治医生提出了吞咽评估请求。三位专家使用渗透-误吸量表(PAS)评估了 56 个 IGI 视频片段,金标准是所有三位专家的共识阅读。另外三位言语病理学家(SLP)使用 PAS 评估了 56 个 DGI 和 IGI 视频片段。PAS 评分 1 和 2 归类为正常范围,PAS 评分 3-5 为病理性喉穿透,PAS 评分 6-8 为误吸。然后确定了 IGI 和 DGI 的正确率,并评估了 IGI 和 DGI 评估的一致性水平。
所有评估者对正常范围的正确率均为 100%,对病理性喉穿透的正确率为 80-100%,对误吸的正确率为 83-100%,对 IGI 的正确率为 100%,对病理性喉穿透的正确率为 90%,对误吸的正确率为 83%,对 DGI 的正确率为 100%。IGI 和 DGI 的kappa 系数显示对异常情况的一致性几乎为完全一致。
对床边老年患者进行的 2-5ml 液体吞咽动态成像显示,在成像后立即从 DGI 视频获得的 SLP 进行的误吸评估是可以接受的。