Bernacer Javier
Mind-Brain Group, Institute for Culture and Society (ICS), University of Navarra, Pamplona, Spain.
International Center of Neuroscience and Ethics (CINET), Tatiana Foundation, Madrid, Spain.
Front Psychol. 2024 Jun 24;15:1371436. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1371436. eCollection 2024.
From an evolutionary point of view, organisms with mutations resulting in maladaptation are an unavoidable result of genetic variability, and they do not usually survive natural selection. Thus, they do not produce benefits for the species. I contend that this is different in humans at two levels. First, the existence of people with disability has been essential for human growth as a species. Human ancestors' evolving cognitive and social abilities were boosted by caring for vulnerable members of the species, including premature offspring and people with disability. Therefore, caregiving was an essential trait of the evolution of humans, intertwined with the development of bipedalism, the hand, face, vocal apparatus, and brain. Second, caring for disability is also a source of growth at a personal level. Even though most scientific literature focuses on the stress and burden caused by caring for people with disability, there is solid evidence to accept caregiving as a source of happiness and flourishing for human beings. Hence, disability still has an essential role in improving human life nowadays. Contrary to this evidence, influential utilitarian bioethicists promote the elimination of disability from modern societies. Following the arguments presented here, this will lead to the withering of society. In conclusion, disability should be acknowledged as an essential source of growth for the human species.
从进化的角度来看,因突变导致适应不良的生物体是遗传变异不可避免的结果,它们通常无法在自然选择中存活下来。因此,它们不会给物种带来益处。我认为,在人类身上这在两个层面有所不同。首先,残疾人的存在对于人类作为一个物种的发展至关重要。人类祖先不断进化的认知和社交能力因照顾物种中的弱势群体而得到提升,这些弱势群体包括早产后代和残疾人。因此,照顾他人是人类进化的一个基本特征,与两足行走、手、脸、发声器官和大脑的发展交织在一起。其次,照顾残疾人也是个人成长的一个源泉。尽管大多数科学文献关注照顾残疾人所带来的压力和负担,但有确凿的证据表明,照顾他人是人类幸福和繁荣的一个源泉。因此,如今残疾在改善人类生活方面仍然起着至关重要的作用。与这一证据相反,有影响力的功利主义生物伦理学家主张从现代社会中消除残疾。根据这里提出的论点,这将导致社会的衰落。总之,残疾应该被视为人类物种成长的一个重要源泉。