Division of Healthcare Delivery, RAND, Washington, DC.
Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts.
JAMA Netw Open. 2024 Jul 1;7(7):e2420853. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.20853.
Telehealth services expanded rapidly during the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE).
To evaluate changes in availability of telehealth services at outpatient mental health treatment facilities (MHTFs) throughout the US during and after the COVID-19 PHE.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this cohort study, callers posing as prospective clients contacted a random sample of 1404 MHTFs drawn from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration's Behavioral Health Treatment Locator from December 2022 to March 2023 (wave 1 [W1]; during PHE). From September to November 2023 (wave 2 [W2]; after PHE), callers recontacted W1 participants. Analyses were conducted in January 2024.
Callers inquired whether MHTFs offered telehealth (yes vs no), and, if yes, whether they offered (1) audio-only telehealth (vs audio and video); (2) telehealth for therapy, medication management, and/or diagnostic services; and (3) telehealth for comorbid alcohol use disorder (AUD). Sustainers (offered telehealth in both waves), late adopters (did not offer telehealth in W1 but did in W2), nonadopters (did not offer telehealth in W1 or W2), and discontinuers (offered telehealth in W1 but not W2) were all compared.
During W2, 1001 MHTFs (86.1%) were successfully recontacted. A total of 713 (71.2%) were located in a metropolitan county, 151 (15.1%) were publicly operated, and 935 (93.4%) accepted Medicaid as payment. The percentage offering telehealth declined from 799 (81.6%) to 765 (79.0%) (odds ratio [OR], 0.84; 95% CI, 0.72-1.00; P < .05). Among MHTFs offering telehealth, a smaller percentage in W2 offered audio-only telehealth (369 [49.3%] vs 244 [34.1%]; OR, 0.53; 95% CI, 0.44-0.64; P < .001) and telehealth for comorbid AUD (559 [76.3%] vs 457 [66.5%]; OR, 0.62; 95% CI, 0.50-0.76; P < .001) compared with W1. In W2, MHTFs were more likely to report telehealth was only available under certain conditions for therapy (141 facilities [18.0%] vs 276 [36.4%]; OR, 2.62; 95% CI, 1.10-3.26; P < .001) and medication management (216 facilities [28.0%] vs 304 [41.3%]; OR, 1.81; 95% CI, 1.48-2.21; P < .001). A total of 684 MHTFs (72.0%) constituted sustainers, 94 (9.9%) were discontinuers, 106 (11.2%) were nonadopters, and 66 (7.0%) were late adopters. Compared with sustainers, discontinuers were less likely to be private for-profit (adjusted OR [aOR], 0.28; 95% CI, 0.11-0.68) or private not-for-profit (aOR, 0.26; 95% CI, 0.14-0.48) after adjustment for facility and area characteristics.
Based on this longitudinal cohort study of 1001 MHTFs, telehealth availability has declined since the PHE end with respect to scope and modality of services, suggesting targeted policies may be necessary to sustain telehealth access.
远程医疗服务在 COVID-19 公共卫生紧急事件 (PHE) 期间迅速扩大。
评估美国各地门诊心理健康治疗机构 (MHTF) 在 COVID-19 PHE 期间和之后远程医疗服务可用性的变化。
设计、设置和参与者:在这项队列研究中,伪装成潜在客户的呼叫者从物质滥用和心理健康服务管理局的行为健康治疗定位器中抽取了 1404 个 MHTF 的随机样本,从 2022 年 12 月至 2023 年 3 月 (第 1 波 [W1];PHE 期间) 进行呼叫。2023 年 9 月至 11 月 (第 2 波 [W2];PHE 之后),呼叫者重新联系了 W1 参与者。分析于 2024 年 1 月进行。
呼叫者询问 MHTF 是否提供远程医疗 (是与否),如果是,他们是否提供 (1) 仅音频远程医疗 (与音频和视频);(2) 用于治疗、药物管理和/或诊断服务的远程医疗;以及 (3) 用于合并酒精使用障碍 (AUD) 的远程医疗。维持者 (在两波中都提供远程医疗)、晚期采用者 (在 W1 中未提供远程医疗,但在 W2 中提供)、非采用者 (在 W1 或 W2 中均未提供远程医疗) 和中断者 (在 W1 中提供远程医疗,但不在 W2 中提供) 均进行了比较。
在 W2 期间,成功重新联系了 1001 个 MHTF (86.1%)。其中 713 个 (71.2%) 位于大都市区县,151 个 (15.1%) 为公有制,935 个 (93.4%) 接受医疗补助作为支付方式。提供远程医疗的比例从 799 个 (81.6%) 下降到 765 个 (79.0%) (优势比 [OR],0.84;95% CI,0.72-1.00;P <.05)。在提供远程医疗的 MHTF 中,在 W2 中提供仅音频远程医疗的比例较小 (369 [49.3%] 与 244 [34.1%];OR,0.53;95% CI,0.44-0.64;P <.001) 和合并 AUD 的远程医疗 (559 [76.3%] 与 457 [66.5%];OR,0.62;95% CI,0.50-0.76;P <.001) 与 W1 相比。在 W2 中,MHTF 更有可能报告远程医疗仅在治疗 (141 个设施 [18.0%] 与 276 个 [36.4%];OR,2.62;95% CI,1.10-3.26;P <.001) 和药物管理 (216 个设施 [28.0%] 与 304 个 [41.3%];OR,1.81;95% CI,1.48-2.21;P <.001) 方面提供远程医疗。共有 684 个 MHTF (72.0%) 构成维持者,94 个 (9.9%) 为中断者,106 个 (11.2%) 为非采用者,66 个 (7.0%) 为晚期采用者。与维持者相比,中断者不太可能是私立营利性 (调整后的优势比 [aOR],0.28;95% CI,0.11-0.68) 或私立非营利性 (aOR,0.26;95% CI,0.14-0.48),调整后的设施和区域特征后。
基于这项对 1001 个 MHTF 的纵向队列研究,自 PHE 结束以来,远程医疗的可用性有所下降,涉及服务的范围和模式,这表明可能需要有针对性的政策来维持远程医疗的获取。