Nuttall F Q, Gannon M C, Wald J L, Ahmed M
J Am Coll Nutr. 1985;4(4):437-50. doi: 10.1080/07315724.1985.10720086.
The 12-hr profiles of plasma glucose and insulin concentrations in 26 normal subjects ingesting a diet high in carbohydrate, protein, or fat have been determined. The diets were isocaloric and were given as three identical meals 4 hrs apart. In males the high carbohydrate diet resulted in glucose profiles similar to those obtained with the standard diet. In females the peak glucose concentration also was not increased but the glucose concentration remained elevated longer after each meal. In both groups the insulin curves followed the glucose curves. The post-meal glucose and insulin areas were significantly increased in the female group. The high protein diet resulted in only a small post-meal glucose rise particularly later in the day in both males and females. However, there was a sharp rise in insulin concentration after each meal. The total insulin area after each meal was nearly as great as with the standard diet. The high fat diet, which contained approximately the same carbohydrate content as the high protein diet, induced a clear increase in glucose concentration after each meal in the female group. However, the peak was progressively delayed with each meal. The insulin curves followed the glucose curves. In males a small, prolonged post-meal increase in glucose was observed after each meal. The insulin concentration increased modestly after the first meal and then remained elevated and changed little after the subsequent meals. These data help to define the glucose and insulin responses to meals varying greatly in protein, carbohydrate, and fat content and further indicate the need to consider the response of males and females separately.
已测定26名正常受试者摄入高碳水化合物、高蛋白或高脂肪饮食后12小时的血浆葡萄糖和胰岛素浓度曲线。这些饮食热量相等,以每隔4小时提供三餐相同食物的方式给予。在男性中,高碳水化合物饮食导致的葡萄糖曲线与标准饮食相似。在女性中,餐后葡萄糖峰值浓度也未升高,但餐后葡萄糖浓度升高持续时间更长。两组的胰岛素曲线均与葡萄糖曲线相符。女性组餐后葡萄糖和胰岛素曲线下面积显著增加。高蛋白饮食仅导致餐后葡萄糖小幅升高,尤其是在一天晚些时候,男性和女性均如此。然而,每餐餐后胰岛素浓度急剧上升。每餐餐后胰岛素曲线下总面积几乎与标准饮食时一样大。高脂肪饮食的碳水化合物含量与高蛋白饮食大致相同,在女性组中每餐餐后均导致葡萄糖浓度明显升高。然而,峰值随每餐逐渐延迟。胰岛素曲线与葡萄糖曲线相符。在男性中,每餐餐后均观察到葡萄糖出现小幅、持续时间较长的升高。第一餐后胰岛素浓度适度升高,随后各餐后保持升高且变化不大。这些数据有助于明确对蛋白质、碳水化合物和脂肪含量差异很大的餐食的葡萄糖和胰岛素反应,并进一步表明有必要分别考虑男性和女性的反应。