Ward Joey, Cox Simon R, Quinn Terry, Lyall Laura M, Strawbridge Rona J, Russell Emma, Pell Jill P, Stewart William, Cullen Breda, Whalley Heather, Lyall Donald M
School of Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, G12 8TB, Glasgow, UK.
School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences, University of Edinburgh, EH8 9JZ, Edinburgh, UK.
Brain Commun. 2024 Jul 2;6(4):fcae220. doi: 10.1093/braincomms/fcae220. eCollection 2024.
Participant motion in brain magnetic resonance imaging is associated with processing problems including potentially non-useable/incomplete data. This has implications for representativeness in research. Few large studies have investigated predictors of increased motion in the first instance. We exploratively tested for association between multiple psychological and physical health traits with concurrent motion during T structural, diffusion, average resting-state and task functional magnetic resonance imaging in = 52 951 UK Biobank imaging subsample participants. These traits included history of cardiometabolic, inflammatory, neurological and psychiatric conditions, as well as concurrent cognitive test scores and anthropometric traits. We tested for stability in motion in participants with longitudinal imaging data ( = 5305, average 2.64 years later). All functional and T structural motion variables were significantly intercorrelated (Pearson range 0.3-0.8, all < 0.001). Diffusion motion variables showed weaker correlations around = 0.1. Most physical and psychological phenotypes showed significant association with at least one measure of increased motion including specifically in participants with complete useable data (highest β = 0.66 for diabetes versus resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging motion). Poorer values in most health traits predicted lower odds of complete imaging data, with the largest association for history of traumatic brain injury (odds ratio = 0.720, 95% confidence interval = 0.562 to 0.923, = 0.009). Worse psychological and physical health are consistent predictors of increased average functional and structural motion during brain imaging and associated with lower odds of complete data. Average motion levels were largely consistent across modalities and longitudinally in participants with repeat data. Together, these findings have implications for representativeness and bias in imaging studies of generally healthy population samples.
脑磁共振成像中的参与者运动与处理问题相关,包括可能无法使用/不完整的数据。这对研究的代表性有影响。很少有大型研究首先调查运动增加的预测因素。我们对52951名英国生物银行成像子样本参与者在T结构、扩散、平均静息状态和任务功能磁共振成像期间,对多种心理和身体健康特征与同时发生的运动之间的关联进行了探索性测试。这些特征包括心血管代谢、炎症、神经和精神疾病史,以及同时进行的认知测试分数和人体测量特征。我们对有纵向成像数据的参与者(n = 5305,平均2.64年后)的运动稳定性进行了测试。所有功能和T结构运动变量都显著相互关联(Pearson相关系数范围为0.3 - 0.8,所有p < 0.001)。扩散运动变量显示出较弱的相关性,约为0.1。大多数身体和心理表型与至少一种运动增加的测量指标显著相关,特别是在拥有完整可用数据的参与者中(糖尿病与静息状态功能磁共振成像运动的最高β = 0.66)。大多数健康特征较差的值预示着完整成像数据的几率较低,其中创伤性脑损伤史的关联最大(优势比 = 0.720,95%置信区间 = 0.562至0.923,p = 0.009)。更差的心理和身体健康是脑成像期间平均功能和结构运动增加的一致预测因素,并且与完整数据的较低几率相关。平均运动水平在不同模态之间以及在有重复数据的参与者中纵向基本一致。总之,这些发现对一般健康人群样本的成像研究中的代表性和偏差有影响。