Bray Riina, Wang Yifan, Argiropoulos Nikolas, Robins Stephanie, Molot John, Pigeon Marie-Andrée, Gaudet Michel, Auger Pierre, Bélanger Emilie, Peris Rohini
Environmental Health Clinic, Women's College Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Association pour la santé environnementale du Québec - Environmental Health Association of Québec, Saint Sauveur, QC, Canada.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 Jul 17;8:e48434. doi: 10.2196/48434.
Multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS) develops in response to repeated small-level chemical exposures or a major exposure in a subset of people, who then experience symptoms that can range from mild to debilitating when exposed to chemicals. The arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic and the stringent health measures put in place may have increased the burden for those living with MCS, as it became more challenging to avoid chemicals that trigger their condition.
This study aimed to better understand the lived experience of Canadians living with MCS during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic.
An online questionnaire was created to ask participants to compare daily living during the pandemic to before March 11, 2020. Data were collected in January and February 2021. Three areas were investigated: (1) environmental exposures to chemical triggers from ambient air (pollution from industry, farming, and traffic) and indoor air (the smell of cleaning products, cooking odors, and smoke); (2) access to, and satisfaction with, health care visits; and (3) how people experiencing MCS rated contact with their social network.
In all, 119 Canadians who had lived with MCS for more than a year completed the questionnaire. The participant sample was mostly female (86.6%, n=103) and highly educated, with 57.1% (n=68) having a university degree. Slightly more than half (57.1%, n=68) were older than 55 years. McNemar chi-square and Wilcoxon signed rank tests were used to evaluate if there were statistically significant changes before ("prepandemic period") and after ("postpandemic period") March 11, 2020. Perceived exposure to pollution from a highway or a road was significantly decreased from the prepandemic to postpandemic period (z=-3.347; P<.001). Analysis of industry or power plants also suggested a significant decrease in the perceived exposure from the prepandemic to postpandemic period (z=-2.152; P=.04). Participants reported an increase in exposure to odors from disinfectants or sanitizers that entered their living environment (P<.001). There was a significant decrease between prepandemic and postpandemic levels of satisfaction when attending in-person meetings with a physician (z=-2.048; P=.04), yet there were no significant differences between prepandemic and postpandemic levels of satisfaction for online or telephone meetings with a physician. Although people with MCS experienced increased social isolation (P<.001), they also reported an increase in understanding from family (P=.03) and a decrease in stigma for wearing personal protective equipment (P<.001).
During the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, people with MCS were impacted by inaccessibility, loss of social support, and barriers to accessing health care. This study highlights unique challenges and possible benefits associated with the COVID-19 pandemic public health measures for individuals living with MCS. These findings can guide decision makers to improve policies on accessibility through appropriate accommodation measures.
多重化学物质敏感症(MCS)是在一部分人反复接触低剂量化学物质或一次重大接触后出现的,这些人随后在接触化学物质时会出现从轻微到使人衰弱的各种症状。新冠疫情的到来以及实施的严格卫生措施可能增加了患有MCS者的负担,因为避免接触引发其病症的化学物质变得更具挑战性。
本研究旨在更好地了解新冠疫情第一年期间加拿大MCS患者的生活经历。
创建了一份在线问卷,要求参与者将疫情期间的日常生活与2020年3月11日之前进行比较。数据于2021年1月和2月收集。调查了三个方面:(1)环境中来自室外空气(工业、农业和交通污染)和室内空气(清洁产品气味、烹饪气味和烟雾)的化学触发物暴露情况;(2)获得医疗就诊的机会以及对医疗就诊的满意度;(3)患有MCS的人对与社交网络接触的评价。
共有119名患有MCS超过一年的加拿大人完成了问卷。参与者样本大多为女性(86.6%,n = 103)且受教育程度高,57.1%(n = 68)拥有大学学位。略超过一半(57.1%,n = 68)的人年龄超过55岁。使用McNemar卡方检验和Wilcoxon符号秩检验来评估2020年3月11日之前(“疫情前时期”)和之后(“疫情后时期”)是否存在统计学上的显著变化。从疫情前到疫情后时期,感知到的来自高速公路或道路的污染暴露显著减少(z = -3.347;P <.001)。对工业或发电厂的分析也表明,从疫情前到疫情后时期,感知到的暴露显著减少(z = -2.152;P =.04)。参与者报告进入其生活环境的消毒剂或清洁剂气味的暴露增加(P <.001)。与医生进行面对面会诊时,疫情前和疫情后时期的满意度水平存在显著下降(z = -2.048;P =.04),然而与医生进行在线或电话会诊时,疫情前和疫情后时期的满意度水平没有显著差异。尽管患有MCS的人经历了社交隔离增加(P <.001),但他们也报告来自家人的理解增加(P =.03)以及佩戴个人防护装备的耻辱感减少(P <.001)。
在新冠疫情的第一年,患有MCS的人受到难以获得帮助、社会支持丧失以及获得医疗保健障碍的影响。本研究突出了新冠疫情公共卫生措施给患有MCS的个人带来的独特挑战和可能的益处。这些发现可以指导决策者通过适当的便利措施改进可达性政策。