Gowenlock Anna Elizabeth, Norbury Courtenay, Rodd Jennifer M
Clinical, Educational, and Health Psychology, University College London, London, UK.
Clinical, Educational, and Health Psychology, UCL, London, UK.
J Cogn. 2024 Jul 17;7(1):57. doi: 10.5334/joc.385. eCollection 2024.
Early exposure to books can benefit language acquisition by expanding children's linguistic experience and engaging them in a shared activity (Nation et al. 2022; Dowdall et al., 2020). Video media (including television) could potentially fulfil a similar role by exposing children to new linguistic phenomena in an engaging setting. However, while many studies have examined the impact of screen-time on cognitive development (for a review see Kostyrka-Allchorne et al., 2017), the findings relating specifically to language remain unclear. The aim of this review is to understand how encountering language content in video media might impact a variety of language skills in children aged 3-11. This review maps the methods and findings of 93 studies that met preregistered criteria with the goal of understanding which factors impact learning outcomes following video exposure. Results from observational (N = 31) and experimental (N = 62) studies reveal a divided literature in which video viewing is linked to short-term benefits for learning specific linguistic structures from high-quality video media, as well as having negative or null long-term associations with standardised language measures. Results highlight various methodological difficulties and limitations faced by experimental and observational approaches and reveal the importance of video quality and viewing context for language learning.
早期接触书籍可以通过拓展儿童的语言体验并让他们参与一项共同活动来促进语言习得(Nation等人,2022年;Dowdall等人,2020年)。视频媒体(包括电视)有可能通过在引人入胜的情境中让儿童接触新的语言现象来发挥类似的作用。然而,虽然许多研究已经考察了屏幕时间对认知发展的影响(综述见Kostyrka-Allchorne等人,2017年),但具体与语言相关的研究结果仍不明确。本综述的目的是了解在视频媒体中接触语言内容如何影响3至11岁儿童的各种语言技能。本综述梳理了93项符合预先注册标准的研究的方法和结果,目的是了解哪些因素会影响视频接触后的学习成果。观察性研究(N = 31)和实验性研究(N = 62)的结果显示,相关文献存在分歧,其中观看视频与从高质量视频媒体中学习特定语言结构的短期益处有关,同时与标准化语言测试存在负面或无关联的长期关系。结果突出了实验性和观察性方法面临的各种方法学困难和局限性,并揭示了视频质量和观看背景对语言学习的重要性。