Bal Mazhar, Kara Aydemir Ayşe Gül, Tepetaş Cengiz Gülüzar Şule, Altındağ Ahmet
Department of Turkish and Social Sciences Education, Faculty of Education, Akdeniz University, Antalya, Turkey.
Department of Educational Sciences, Akdeniz University, Antalya, Turkey.
PLoS One. 2024 Dec 26;19(12):e0314540. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314540. eCollection 2024.
This systematic review study examines the relationship between language development, executive function, and screen time in early childhood. The early childhood period is a crucial phase for the development of the brain, during which fundamental language and executive function skills undergo rapid evolution. This review synthesizes findings from 14 peer-reviewed studies that focused on language development, executive function, and screen time together to provide a comprehensive understanding of their relationship. The findings of current study were categorized under four themes: screen content and adherence to guidelines, parent-child interaction and the family context, passive and active screen time, and attention issues. The findings suggest that interactive and educational screen content may positively influence language development and executive functions when aligned with recommended screen time guidelines. In contrast, excessive passive screen time, such as watching television, has been associated with negative impacts on cognitive and social skills, particularly affecting attention, memory, and emotional regulation. The prevalence of attention problems is found to be higher in individuals who engage in high levels of screen time. This highlights the necessity for balanced consumption of screen media. The review emphasizes the pivotal role of parent-child interaction, where high-quality engagement and verbal scaffolding during screen time can mitigate adverse effects. Furthermore, socioeconomic and cultural factors also play a significant role. Higher socioeconomic status (SES) families are better able to manage screen time and leverage educational content to support development. These findings have the potential to inform the actions of parents, educators, and policymakers. Adherence to recommended screen time guidelines can mitigate the potential negative impact on executive functions and language skills. Furthermore, the importance of limiting passive screen time and ensuring a balance between screen use and real-world interactions and play opportunities is also highlighted.
这项系统综述研究探讨了幼儿期语言发展、执行功能与屏幕使用时间之间的关系。幼儿期是大脑发育的关键阶段,在此期间,基本的语言和执行功能技能会迅速发展。本综述综合了14项同行评审研究的结果,这些研究共同关注语言发展、执行功能和屏幕使用时间,以全面了解它们之间的关系。当前研究的结果分为四个主题:屏幕内容与指南遵守情况、亲子互动与家庭环境、被动和主动屏幕使用时间以及注意力问题。研究结果表明,当与推荐的屏幕使用时间指南一致时,互动性和教育性的屏幕内容可能会对语言发展和执行功能产生积极影响。相比之下,过多的被动屏幕使用时间,如看电视,与对认知和社交技能的负面影响有关,尤其会影响注意力、记忆力和情绪调节。在屏幕使用时间较长的个体中,注意力问题的发生率更高。这凸显了平衡使用屏幕媒体的必要性。该综述强调了亲子互动的关键作用,即在屏幕使用期间高质量的互动和言语支持可以减轻负面影响。此外,社会经济和文化因素也起着重要作用。社会经济地位较高的家庭更有能力管理屏幕使用时间,并利用教育内容来支持发展。这些发现有可能为家长、教育工作者和政策制定者的行动提供参考。遵守推荐的屏幕使用时间指南可以减轻对执行功能和语言技能的潜在负面影响。此外,还强调了限制被动屏幕使用时间以及确保屏幕使用与现实世界互动和玩耍机会之间平衡的重要性。