Edwards Rachael C, Kneale Dylan, Stansfield Claire, Lester Sarah
Evidence for Policy and Practice Information Centre, UCL Social Research Institute, Institute of Education, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, United Kingdom.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2024 Jul 31;22(1):88. doi: 10.1186/s12961-024-01162-2.
Embedded researchers are a novel intervention to improve the translation of research evidence into policy and practice settings, including public health. These roles are being implemented with increasing popularity, but they often lack clear evaluative frameworks. Understanding initial levels of research activity, including associated barriers and opportunities, is essential to developing theories of change and thus shaping the roles and defining expectations. We aimed to identify the principal determinants of research activity in public health that contextualise embedded researcher roles, including attributes of the embedded researcher themselves.
We undertook seventeen semi-structured interviews with embedded researchers in diverse public health settings in English local government. Interviews were analysed using thematic analysis.
We identified thirteen interlinked determinants of research activity within local government public health settings. Research and interpersonal skills, as well as pre-existing connections and knowledge within local government, were highly valued individual attributes for embedded researchers. Resource deficiencies (funding, time, and infrastructure) were primary barriers to research activity, whereas a strong local appetite for evidence informed decision making presented a valuable opportunity. However, there was inconsistencies across public health teams relating to perceptions of what constituted "research" and the resources that would be required.
Our results suggest that successful embedded researchers will have equally strong research and communication skills and should be offered mentorship and clear career progression pathways. Perceptions of research within local government are closely linked to resource deficiencies and senior endorsement. Embedded researchers could benefit from taking the time to develop locally contextualised knowledge of this research culture. Theories of change for embedded researchers should conceptualise the interconnections across individual, interpersonal, and organisational barriers and opportunities underlying local government research activity. Further research is needed to identify methods for exploring the influence of embedded researchers as well as to unpack the stages of research activity within local government and the associated behaviours.
嵌入式研究人员是一种新型干预措施,旨在促进研究证据转化为政策和实践环境,包括公共卫生领域。这些角色的应用越来越广泛,但往往缺乏明确的评估框架。了解研究活动的初始水平,包括相关的障碍和机遇,对于构建变革理论从而塑造这些角色并明确期望至关重要。我们旨在确定公共卫生领域研究活动的主要决定因素,这些因素构成了嵌入式研究人员角色的背景,包括嵌入式研究人员自身的属性。
我们对英国地方政府不同公共卫生环境中的嵌入式研究人员进行了17次半结构化访谈。访谈采用主题分析法进行分析。
我们确定了地方政府公共卫生环境中研究活动的13个相互关联的决定因素。研究和人际交往能力,以及地方政府内部已有的联系和知识,是嵌入式研究人员高度重视的个人属性。资源不足(资金、时间和基础设施)是研究活动的主要障碍,而地方对循证决策的强烈意愿提供了一个宝贵的机会。然而,不同公共卫生团队对“研究”的构成以及所需资源的看法存在不一致。
我们的结果表明,成功的嵌入式研究人员应具备同样强大的研究和沟通能力,并应获得指导和明确的职业发展路径。地方政府对研究的认知与资源不足和高级管理层的支持密切相关。嵌入式研究人员可以从花时间深入了解这种研究文化的地方背景知识中受益。嵌入式研究人员的变革理论应将个体、人际和组织层面的障碍与机遇之间的相互联系概念化,这些障碍与机遇构成了地方政府研究活动的基础。需要进一步研究以确定探索嵌入式研究人员影响力的方法,以及剖析地方政府内部研究活动的阶段和相关行为。