van Vliet Niels K, Atsma Femke, Boer Theo A, van den Brink Bart, Groenewoud A Stef
Transfore, Dimence Group, Deventer, The Netherlands.
Scientific Institute for Quality in Health Care, Radboud University Medical Centre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Death Stud. 2024 Aug 2:1-9. doi: 10.1080/07481187.2024.2386059.
In the Netherlands, rates of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (henceforth "EPAS") display substantial variation at the municipal level. If a similar variation can be found in non-assisted suicide (henceforth "suicide"), this may enable us to establish a possible correlation between these variations. This cross-sectional study assessed proportions of suicide in the years 2013-2017 in The Netherlands. Negative binomial regression analysis was performed to identify potential explanatory variables and to calculate adjusted proportions. The magnitude of variation was calculated by ratios between the highest and lowest municipality proportions. Outliers were detected by Funnel Plots. A possible correlation between suicide and EPAS was calculated. From 2013-2017 the suicide rate between Dutch municipalities varied by a factor 6.7. This variation could only be partially explained by gender, political orientation, the availability of voluntary workers, and mobility limitations. No correlation was found with the variation in EPAS. A "waterbed effect" between suicides and EPAS-cases could not be confirmed. Advice for further research is given.
在荷兰,安乐死和医生协助自杀(以下简称“EPAS”)的发生率在市政层面存在显著差异。如果在非协助自杀(以下简称“自杀”)中也能发现类似的差异,这或许能使我们确定这些差异之间可能存在的关联。这项横断面研究评估了2013年至2017年荷兰的自杀比例。进行了负二项回归分析,以确定潜在的解释变量并计算调整后的比例。变异程度通过最高和最低市政比例之间的比率来计算。通过漏斗图检测异常值。计算了自杀与EPAS之间可能的相关性。2013年至2017年期间,荷兰各市政当局之间的自杀率相差6.7倍。这种差异只能部分地由性别、政治倾向、志愿者的可获得性以及行动不便来解释。未发现与EPAS的差异存在相关性。自杀与EPAS案例之间的“水床效应”无法得到证实。给出了进一步研究的建议。