Osuna-Caballero Salvador, Rubiales Diego, Annicchiarico Paolo, Nazzicari Nelson, Rispail Nicolas
Institute for Sustainable Agriculture, Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), Cordoba, Spain.
Research Centre for Animal Production and Aquaculture, Spanish National Research Council (CREA), Lodi, Italy.
Front Plant Sci. 2024 Jul 23;15:1429802. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2024.1429802. eCollection 2024.
Genomic selection (GS) has become an indispensable tool in modern plant breeding, particularly for complex traits. This study aimed to assess the efficacy of GS in predicting rust () resistance in pea (), using a panel of 320 pea accessions and a set of 26,045 Silico-Diversity Arrays Technology (Silico-DArT) markers. We compared the prediction abilities of different GS models and explored the impact of incorporating marker × environment (M×E) interaction as a covariate in the GBLUP (genomic best linear unbiased prediction) model. The analysis included phenotyping data from both field and controlled conditions. We assessed the predictive accuracies of different cross-validation strategies and compared the efficiency of using single traits versus a multi-trait index, based on factor analysis and ideotype-design (FAI-BLUP), which combines traits from controlled conditions. The GBLUP model, particularly when modified to include M×E interactions, consistently outperformed other models, demonstrating its suitability for traits affected by complex genotype-environment interactions (GEI). The best predictive ability (0.635) was achieved using the FAI-BLUP approach within the Bayesian Lasso (BL) model. The inclusion of M×E interactions significantly enhanced prediction accuracy across diverse environments in GBLUP models, although it did not markedly improve predictions for non-phenotyped lines. These findings underscore the variability of predictive abilities due to GEI and the effectiveness of multi-trait approaches in addressing complex traits. Overall, our study illustrates the potential of GS, especially when employing a multi-trait index like FAI-BLUP and accounting for M×E interactions, in pea breeding programs focused on rust resistance.
基因组选择(GS)已成为现代植物育种中不可或缺的工具,尤其是对于复杂性状而言。本研究旨在利用一组320份豌豆种质和一组26,045个硅基多样性阵列技术(Silico-DArT)标记,评估GS在预测豌豆锈病抗性方面的功效。我们比较了不同GS模型的预测能力,并探讨了在基因组最佳线性无偏预测(GBLUP)模型中纳入标记×环境(M×E)互作作为协变量的影响。分析包括来自田间和控制条件下的表型数据。我们评估了不同交叉验证策略的预测准确性,并基于因子分析和理想型设计(FAI-BLUP)比较了使用单性状与多性状指数的效率,FAI-BLUP结合了控制条件下的性状。GBLUP模型,特别是在经过修改以纳入M×E互作时,始终优于其他模型,表明其适用于受复杂基因型-环境互作(GEI)影响的性状。在贝叶斯套索(BL)模型中使用FAI-BLUP方法实现了最佳预测能力(0.635)。在GBLUP模型中纳入M×E互作显著提高了不同环境下的预测准确性,尽管对未进行表型测定的品系预测没有明显改善。这些发现强调了由于GEI导致的预测能力的变异性以及多性状方法在解决复杂性状方面的有效性。总体而言,我们的研究说明了GS的潜力,特别是在专注于锈病抗性的豌豆育种计划中采用FAI-BLUP等多性状指数并考虑M×E互作时。