National Crime Victims Research and Treatment Center, Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC 29425, USA.
Clinical Child Psychology Program, University of Kansas, Dole Human Development Building, 1000 Sunnyside Avenue, Lawrence, KS 66045, USA.
Child Abuse Negl. 2024 Sep;155:106994. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2024.106994. Epub 2024 Aug 17.
Numerous methods are used in the measurement of child maltreatment (CM) exposure. As a science, it is necessary that the field of CM research evaluate its measurement approaches periodically to ensure that the common approaches are the best approaches. A prominent method for measuring CM in research as a predictor variable is to conceptualize CM as a two-level, yes/no binary variable (e.g., 0 = No CM exposure, 1 = CM exposure). While there is no consensus on what method is the best approach for measuring CM, empirical evidence suggests that the binary measurement approach to CM has significant limitations. The current paper sought to progress the field of CM and trauma research forward by reviewing several lines of research demonstrating why the use of a binary yes/no CM measurement approach is problematic. As evidence for why a binary measurement of CM should be halted, this paper reviews research on: why the characteristics or details of CM exposure matter, risk of CM "contamination," and CM's relation with environmental or systemic factors. The ethical and clinical implications of a CM binary measurement approach are also discussed. Several recommendations for the field are provided on how researchers can improve the measurement of CM and ensure accurate and replicable studies are being published.
有许多方法可用于儿童虐待(CM)暴露的测量。作为一门科学,CM 研究领域有必要定期评估其测量方法,以确保常用方法是最佳方法。将 CM 概念化为二水平、是/否二进制变量(例如,0=无 CM 暴露,1=CM 暴露)是研究中作为预测变量测量 CM 的一种突出方法。虽然对于哪种方法是测量 CM 的最佳方法尚无共识,但实证证据表明,CM 的二进制测量方法存在重大局限性。本文旨在通过回顾几条研究线来推进 CM 和创伤研究领域的发展,这些研究线表明为什么使用二进制是/否 CM 测量方法存在问题。为了说明为什么应该停止使用 CM 的二进制测量,本文回顾了关于以下内容的研究:CM 暴露的特征或细节为何重要、CM 的“污染”风险,以及 CM 与环境或系统因素的关系。还讨论了 CM 二进制测量方法的伦理和临床意义。本文就研究人员如何改进 CM 的测量以及确保发表准确和可重复的研究,为该领域提供了一些建议。