Research Center, Parker University, Dallas, Texas, United States of America.
Division of Research and Innovation, Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2024 Aug 19;19(8):e0309069. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0309069. eCollection 2024.
This prospective, community-based, active surveillance study aimed to report the incidence of moderate, severe, and serious adverse events (AEs) after chiropractic (n = 100) / physiotherapist (n = 50) visit in offices throughout North America between October-2015 and December-2017. Three content-validated questionnaires were used to collect AE information: two completed by the patient (pre-treatment [T0] and 2-7 days post-treatment [T2]) and one completed by the provider immediately post-treatment [T1]. Any new or worsened symptom was considered an AE and further classified as mild, moderate, severe or serious. From the 42 participating providers (31 chiropractors; 11 physiotherapists), 3819 patient visits had complete T0 and T1 assessments. The patients were on average 50±18 years of age and 62.5% females. Neck/back pain was the most common presenting condition (70.0%) with 24.3% of patients reporting no condition/preventative care. From the patients visits with a complete T2 assessment (n = 2136 patient visits, 55.9%), 21.3% reported an AE, of which: 7.9% were mild, 6.2% moderate, 3.7% severe, 1.5% serious, and 2.0% had missing severity rating. The most common symptoms reported with moderate or higher severity were discomfort/pain, stiffness, difficulty walking and headache. This study provides valuable information for patients and providers regarding incidence and severity of AEs following patient visits in multiple community-based professions. These findings can be used to inform patients of what AEs may occur and future research opportunities can focus on mitigating common AEs.
这项前瞻性、基于社区的主动监测研究旨在报告 2015 年 10 月至 2017 年 12 月期间,在北美的诊所中,接受整脊治疗(n=100)/物理治疗(n=50)后,中度、重度和严重不良事件(AE)的发生率。使用三个经过内容验证的问卷收集 AE 信息:患者完成的两个(治疗前[T0]和治疗后 2-7 天[T2])和提供者在治疗后立即完成的一个(T1)。任何新的或恶化的症状都被认为是 AE,并进一步分为轻度、中度、重度或严重。在 42 名参与提供者(31 名脊椎按摩师;11 名物理治疗师)中,有 3819 次患者就诊完成了 T0 和 T1 评估。患者平均年龄为 50±18 岁,62.5%为女性。颈部/背部疼痛是最常见的首发症状(70.0%),24.3%的患者无任何症状/预防保健。在接受完整 T2 评估的患者就诊中(n=2136 次就诊,55.9%),21.3%报告了 AE,其中:7.9%为轻度,6.2%为中度,3.7%为重度,1.5%为严重,2.0%为严重程度缺失。报告中度或更高严重程度的最常见症状是不适/疼痛、僵硬、行走困难和头痛。这项研究为患者和提供者提供了有关在多个基于社区的专业中就诊后 AE 的发生率和严重程度的有价值信息。这些发现可用于告知患者可能发生的 AE,未来的研究机会可以集中在减轻常见 AE 上。