Bayer AG, Berlin, Germany.
Department of Medical Statistics, University Medical Center Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany.
Ther Innov Regul Sci. 2024 Nov;58(6):1080-1093. doi: 10.1007/s43441-024-00689-4. Epub 2024 Aug 21.
Whereas AI/ML methods were considered experimental tools in clinical development for some time, nowadays they are widely available. However, stakeholders in the health care industry still need to answer the question which role these methods can realistically play and what standards should be adhered to. Clinical research in late-stage clinical development has particular requirements in terms of robustness, transparency and traceability. These standards should also be adhered to when applying AI/ML methods. Currently there is some formal regulatory guidance available, but this is more directed at settings where a device or medical software is investigated. Here we focus on the application of AI/ML methods in late-stage clinical drug development, i.e. in a setting where currently less guidance is available. This is done via first summarizing available regulatory guidance and work done by regulatory statisticians followed by the presentation of an industry application where the influence of extensive sets of baseline characteristics on the treatment effect can be investigated by applying ML-methods in a standardized manner with intuitive graphical displays leveraging explainable AI methods. The paper aims at stimulating discussions on the role such analyses can play in general rather than advocating for a particular AI/ML-method or indication where such methods could be meaningful.
虽然人工智能/机器学习方法在一段时间内被认为是临床开发中的实验工具,但现在它们已经广泛应用。然而,医疗保健行业的利益相关者仍需要回答这些方法可以发挥什么样的实际作用以及应遵循哪些标准的问题。后期临床开发中的临床研究在稳健性、透明度和可追溯性方面有特殊要求。在应用人工智能/机器学习方法时也应遵循这些标准。目前有一些正式的监管指南,但这更多地针对正在研究设备或医疗软件的情况。在这里,我们重点关注人工智能/机器学习方法在后期临床药物开发中的应用,即在目前指导较少的情况下。这是通过首先总结可用的监管指南和监管统计学家的工作来实现的,然后介绍一个行业应用案例,其中可以通过应用机器学习方法以直观的图形显示以标准化的方式来研究大量基线特征对治疗效果的影响,利用可解释的人工智能方法。本文旨在激发关于此类分析可以发挥的作用的讨论,而不是倡导在特定的人工智能/机器学习方法或指示中使用此类方法是有意义的。