Esandi M E, Ortiz Z, Bernabei V, Villalba N B, Liggio S, Della Maggiora M, García N A, Bruzzone A, Blanco G, Prieto Merino D, Legido Quigley H, Perel P
Instituto de Investigaciones Epidemiológicas, Academia Nacional de Medicina de Buenos Aires, Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Departamento de Economía, Universidad Nacional del Sur, Bahía Blanca, Provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Front Health Serv. 2024 Aug 8;4:1263331. doi: 10.3389/frhs.2024.1263331. eCollection 2024.
While pharmacists-led interventions in hypertension have proven effective in high-income countries, their implementation and impact in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) remain limited. This study assessed the implementation and outcomes of the hypertension program FarmaTeCuida (FTC), which integrated community pharmacies into the public primary care level using information and communication technologies. The study took place during the pandemic in General Pueyrredón, Buenos Aires, Argentina, so modifications to the implementation strategy and expected outcomes were also analyzed.
A mixed-methods study was conducted using the non-adoption, abandonment, scaling-up, dissemination, and sustainability (NASSS) conceptual model. Qualitative in-depth interviews were conducted with key stakeholders using snowball sampling until thematic saturation was achieved. The quantitative approach employed a quasi-experimental, prospective, longitudinal design in a cohort of hypertensive patients enrolled in the FTC program since October 2020 to March 2022. Adoption, access, adherence to follow-up, and blood pressure levels were assessed. Clinical outcomes were compared to a cohort of hypertensive patients attending primary health care centers (PHCCs) in 2021 but not enrolled in the FTC program. Routine data from this cohort was obtained from the municipal health information system (HIS).
Out of 33 PHCCs, 23 adopted the FTC program, but only four collaborated with community pharmacies. A total of 440 patients were recruited, with 399 (91%) enrolled at PHCCs. Hypertension was detected in 63% (279/440) of cases at the first visit (113 were possible hypertensive patients; 26 new hypertensive patients and 140 already diagnosed). During follow-up, FTC identified 52 new hypertensive patients (12% out of 440). Reduction of systolic blood pressure (SBP) was observed in patients enrolled in both the FTC program and the comparison group over 60 days. In the multivariate analysis that included all hypertensive patient (FTC and HIS) we found strong evidence that for each month of follow up, SBP was reduced by 1.12 mmHg; however, we did not find any significant effect of the FTC program on SBP trend (interaction FTC*months has a -value = 0.23). The pandemic was identified as the main reason for the program's underperformance; in addition we identified barriers related to technology, patient suitability, implementation team characteristics, and organizational factors.
Our study, grounded in the NASSS model, highlights the profound complexity of introducing innovative strategies in low- and middle-income settings. Despite substantial challenges posed by the pandemic, these obstacles provided valuable insights, identified areas for improvement, and informed strategies essential for reshaping the care paradigm for conditions like hypertension in resource-constrained environments.
虽然在高收入国家,由药剂师主导的高血压干预措施已被证明是有效的,但在低收入和中等收入国家(LMIC),这些措施的实施和影响仍然有限。本研究评估了高血压项目FarmaTeCuida(FTC)的实施情况和成果,该项目利用信息和通信技术将社区药房纳入公共初级保健层面。该研究在阿根廷布宜诺斯艾利斯省普埃雷东将军镇的疫情期间进行,因此还分析了实施策略的调整和预期成果。
采用非采用、放弃、扩大规模、传播和可持续性(NASSS)概念模型进行了一项混合方法研究。采用雪球抽样法对关键利益相关者进行定性深入访谈,直至达到主题饱和。定量方法采用准实验、前瞻性、纵向设计,研究对象为2020年10月至2022年3月期间纳入FTC项目的高血压患者队列。评估了采用情况、可及性、随访依从性和血压水平。将临床结果与2021年在初级卫生保健中心(PHCC)就诊但未纳入FTC项目的高血压患者队列进行比较。该队列的常规数据来自市政卫生信息系统(HIS)。
在33个PHCC中,23个采用了FTC项目,但只有4个与社区药房合作。共招募了440名患者,其中399名(91%)在PHCC登记。首次就诊时,63%(279/440)的病例检测出高血压(113例可能为高血压患者;26例新诊断高血压患者和140例已确诊患者)。在随访期间,FTC项目识别出52例新的高血压患者(占440例的12%)。在60天内,FTC项目组和对照组的患者收缩压(SBP)均有所下降。在包括所有高血压患者(FTC项目组和HIS组)的多变量分析中,我们发现有力证据表明,每随访一个月,SBP下降1.12 mmHg;然而,我们没有发现FTC项目对SBP趋势有任何显著影响(交互项FTC*月的P值=0.23)。疫情被确定为该项目表现不佳的主要原因;此外,我们还识别出与技术、患者适用性、实施团队特征和组织因素相关的障碍。
我们基于NASSS模型的研究强调了在低收入和中等收入环境中引入创新策略的深刻复杂性。尽管疫情带来了巨大挑战,但这些障碍提供了宝贵的见解,确定了改进领域,并为在资源有限的环境中重塑高血压等疾病护理模式的必要策略提供了信息。