Institute for Complementary and Integrative Medicine, University Hospital Zurich and University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Institute of Social Medicine, Epidemiology and Health Economics, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Corporate member of Freie Universität Berlin, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, and Berlin Institute of Health, Berlin, Germany.
JMIR Med Educ. 2024 Aug 22;10:e50545. doi: 10.2196/50545.
Text-generating artificial intelligence (AI) such as ChatGPT offers many opportunities and challenges in medical education. Acquiring practical skills necessary for using AI in a clinical context is crucial, especially for medical education.
This explorative study aimed to investigate the feasibility of integrating ChatGPT into teaching units and to evaluate the course and the importance of AI-related competencies for medical students. Since a possible application of ChatGPT in the medical field could be the generation of information for patients, we further investigated how such information is perceived by students in terms of persuasiveness and quality.
ChatGPT was integrated into 3 different teaching units of a blended learning course for medical students. Using a mixed methods approach, quantitative and qualitative data were collected. As baseline data, we assessed students' characteristics, including their openness to digital innovation. The students evaluated the integration of ChatGPT into the course and shared their thoughts regarding the future of text-generating AI in medical education. The course was evaluated based on the Kirkpatrick Model, with satisfaction, learning progress, and applicable knowledge considered as key assessment levels. In ChatGPT-integrating teaching units, students evaluated videos featuring information for patients regarding their persuasiveness on treatment expectations in a self-experience experiment and critically reviewed information for patients written using ChatGPT 3.5 based on different prompts.
A total of 52 medical students participated in the study. The comprehensive evaluation of the course revealed elevated levels of satisfaction, learning progress, and applicability specifically in relation to the ChatGPT-integrating teaching units. Furthermore, all evaluation levels demonstrated an association with each other. Higher openness to digital innovation was associated with higher satisfaction and, to a lesser extent, with higher applicability. AI-related competencies in other courses of the medical curriculum were perceived as highly important by medical students. Qualitative analysis highlighted potential use cases of ChatGPT in teaching and learning. In ChatGPT-integrating teaching units, students rated information for patients generated using a basic ChatGPT prompt as "moderate" in terms of comprehensibility, patient safety, and the correct application of communication rules taught during the course. The students' ratings were considerably improved using an extended prompt. The same text, however, showed the smallest increase in treatment expectations when compared with information provided by humans (patient, clinician, and expert) via videos.
This study offers valuable insights into integrating the development of AI competencies into a blended learning course. Integration of ChatGPT enhanced learning experiences for medical students.
文本生成式人工智能(如 ChatGPT)在医学教育中提供了许多机会和挑战。在临床环境中使用 AI 所需的实践技能至关重要,特别是对于医学教育而言。
本探索性研究旨在调查将 ChatGPT 整合到教学单元中的可行性,并评估该课程以及 AI 相关能力对医学生的重要性。由于 ChatGPT 在医学领域的潜在应用可能是为患者生成信息,因此我们进一步研究了学生在说服力和质量方面如何看待此类信息。
将 ChatGPT 整合到医学生混合学习课程的 3 个不同教学单元中。使用混合方法收集定量和定性数据。作为基线数据,我们评估了学生的特征,包括他们对数字创新的开放程度。学生评估了将 ChatGPT 整合到课程中的情况,并分享了他们对医学教育中生成式 AI 未来的看法。根据柯克帕特里克模型评估课程,满意度、学习进展和适用知识被视为关键评估水平。在整合了 ChatGPT 的教学单元中,学生在自我体验实验中评估了针对患者的信息视频,评估其在治疗预期方面的说服力,并根据不同提示批判性地审查了使用 ChatGPT 3.5 生成的针对患者的信息。
共有 52 名医学生参与了研究。该课程的综合评估显示,满意度、学习进展和适用性水平均有所提高,特别是在整合了 ChatGPT 的教学单元中。此外,所有评估水平之间均存在关联。对数字创新的开放程度越高,满意度越高,而与适用性的关联度则稍低。医学生认为医学课程中的其他 AI 相关能力非常重要。定性分析突出了 ChatGPT 在教学中的潜在用例。在整合了 ChatGPT 的教学单元中,学生对使用基本 ChatGPT 提示生成的针对患者的信息的可理解性、患者安全性和课程中教授的正确沟通规则的应用评价为“中等”。使用扩展提示后,学生的评分有了明显提高。然而,与通过视频由患者、临床医生和专家提供的信息相比,该文本在治疗预期方面的提升最小。
本研究为将 AI 能力的发展纳入混合学习课程提供了有价值的见解。将 ChatGPT 整合到医学教育中提高了医学生的学习体验。