Agricultural Engineering Department, Faculty of Agriculture, Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt.
Department of Biology, College of Science, Qassim University, Unaizah, Saudi Arabia.
PLoS One. 2024 Aug 26;19(8):e0308826. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0308826. eCollection 2024.
Estimation of fruit quality parameters are usually based on destructive techniques which are tedious, costly and unreliable when dealing with huge amounts of fruits. Alternatively, non-destructive techniques such as image processing and spectral reflectance would be useful in rapid detection of fruit quality parameters. This research study aimed to assess the potential of image processing, spectral reflectance indices (SRIs), and machine learning models such as decision tree (DT) and random forest (RF) to qualitatively estimate characteristics of mandarin and tomato fruits at different ripening stages. Quality parameters such as chlorophyll a (Chl a), chlorophyll b (Chl b), total soluble solids (TSS), titratable acidity (TA), TSS/TA, carotenoids (car), lycopene and firmness were measured. The results showed that Red-Blue-Green (RGB) indices and newly developed SRIs demonstrated high efficiency for quantifying different fruit properties. For example, the R2 of the relationships between all RGB indices (RGBI) and measured parameters varied between 0.62 and 0.96 for mandarin and varied between 0.29 and 0.90 for tomato. The RGBI such as visible atmospheric resistant index (VARI) and normalized red (Rn) presented the highest R2 = 0.96 with car of mandarin fruits. While excess red vegetation index (ExR) presented the highest R2 = 0.84 with car of tomato fruits. The SRIs such as RSI 710,600, and R730,650 showed the greatest R2 values with respect to Chl a (R2 = 0.80) for mandarin fruits while the GI had the greatest R2 with Chl a (R2 = 0.68) for tomato fruits. Combining RGB and SRIs with DT and RF models would be a robust strategy for estimating eight observed variables associated with reasonable accuracy. Regarding mandarin fruits, in the task of predicting Chl a, the DT-2HV model delivered exceptional results, registering an R2 of 0.993 with an RMSE of 0.149 for the training set, and an R2 of 0.991 with an RMSE of 0.114 for the validation set. As well as for tomato fruits, the DT-5HV model demonstrated exemplary performance in the Chl a prediction, achieving an R2 of 0.905 and an RMSE of 0.077 for the training dataset, and an R2 of 0.785 with an RMSE of 0.077 for the validation dataset. The overall outcomes showed that the RGB, newly SRIs as well as DT and RF based RGBI, and SRIs could be used to evaluate the measured parameters of mandarin and tomato fruits.
果实品质参数的估计通常基于破坏性技术,这些技术在处理大量果实时既繁琐、昂贵又不可靠。相比之下,图像处理和光谱反射率等非破坏性技术可用于快速检测果实品质参数。本研究旨在评估图像处理、光谱反射率指数 (SRIs) 和决策树 (DT) 和随机森林 (RF) 等机器学习模型在不同成熟阶段定性估计柑橘和番茄果实特性的潜力。测量了叶绿素 a (Chl a)、叶绿素 b (Chl b)、总可溶性固体 (TSS)、可滴定酸度 (TA)、TSS/TA、类胡萝卜素 (car)、番茄红素和硬度等品质参数。结果表明,红-蓝-绿 (RGB) 指数和新开发的 SRI 可高效量化不同果实特性。例如,柑橘果实所有 RGB 指数 (RGBI) 与测量参数之间的 R2 范围为 0.62 至 0.96,番茄果实的 R2 范围为 0.29 至 0.90。可见大气阻力指数 (VARI) 和归一化红色 (Rn) 等 RGBI 与柑橘果实的 car 具有最高的 R2=0.96。而番茄果实中 ExR 具有最高的 R2=0.84 与 car 相关。对于柑橘果实,RSI 710、600 和 R730、650 等 SRI 与 Chl a 的 R2 值最大 (R2=0.80),而 GI 与 Chl a 的 R2 值最大 (R2=0.68)。结合 RGB 和 SRI 与 DT 和 RF 模型,对于预测八个与果实品质相关的变量是一种稳健的策略,预测结果具有合理的准确性。对于柑橘果实,在预测 Chl a 的任务中,DT-2HV 模型表现出色,训练集的 R2 为 0.993,RMSE 为 0.149,验证集的 R2 为 0.991,RMSE 为 0.114。对于番茄果实,DT-5HV 模型在预测 Chl a 方面表现出色,训练数据集的 R2 为 0.905,RMSE 为 0.077,验证数据集的 R2 为 0.785,RMSE 为 0.077。总体结果表明,RGB、新的 SRI 以及基于 DT 和 RF 的 RGBI 和 SRI 可用于评估柑橘和番茄果实的测量参数。