Institute of Health Policy, Management & Evaluation, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Centre for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety, Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
PLoS One. 2024 Aug 28;19(8):e0309417. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0309417. eCollection 2024.
Quality improvement approaches are increasingly being used to address the problem of healthcare's climate and ecological impact. While sustainability is increasingly recognized as a domain of quality, consensus is lacking on the most appropriate measures and metrics for those looking to reduce ecological impacts through quality improvement initiatives. We propose a scoping review to summarize approaches for selecting and quantifying ecological impacts in the published quality improvement literature. We will search multiple electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, and Scopus) from 2000 onwards, to identify published quality improvement initiatives in the human healthcare setting intended to address ecological impact with at least one quantitative measure of ecological impact, such as kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent greenhouse gas. Two independent reviewers working in parallel will screen studies for inclusion and abstract study data, including publication, study, and ecological impact characteristics. Charted data will be synthesized narratively as well as with descriptive tables, figures, and summary statistics. In doing so, we will map areas of relative focus as well as gaps in the measurement of ecological impact across quality improvement initiatives. This map can in turn be used to raise awareness of ecological impacts requiring broader consideration, encouraging holistic and clinically relevant approaches to measuring ecological impact in future quality improvement work.
质量改进方法越来越多地被用于解决医疗保健的气候和生态影响问题。虽然可持续性越来越被认为是质量的一个领域,但对于那些希望通过质量改进计划减少生态影响的人来说,缺乏关于最合适的措施和指标的共识。我们建议进行范围综述,以总结在已发表的质量改进文献中选择和量化生态影响的方法。我们将从 2000 年开始,在多个电子数据库(MEDLINE、EMBASE、CINAHL 和 Scopus)中搜索,以确定已发表的旨在解决生态影响的人类医疗保健环境中的质量改进计划,这些计划至少使用一种生态影响的定量措施,例如二氧化碳当量温室气体公斤数。两名独立的平行审查员将筛选纳入的研究并提取研究数据,包括出版物、研究和生态影响特征。图表数据将以叙述性方式以及描述性表格、图表和汇总统计数据进行综合。通过这样做,我们将绘制出质量改进计划中生态影响测量的相对重点领域以及差距。反过来,这张地图可以提高对需要更广泛考虑的生态影响的认识,鼓励在未来的质量改进工作中采取整体和临床相关的方法来测量生态影响。