Sakaue Motoharu, Oishi Motoharu, Ozawa Aisa, Tsukamoto Atsushi, Kayanuma Hideki, Ichihara Nobutsune
Laboratory of Anatomy II, Department of Veterinary Medicine, School of Veterinary Medicine, Azabu University, Kanagawa, Japan.
Laboratory of Anatomy I, Department of Veterinary Medicine, School of Veterinary Medicine, Azabu University, Kanagawa, Japan.
J Vet Med Sci. 2024 Oct 1;86(10):1081-1088. doi: 10.1292/jvms.24-0021. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
Three-dimensional (3D)-printed models of bones are a convenient and durable alternative to real bone specimens, and they have been used in anatomy laboratories. It is necessary to identify the precise advantages of 3D-printed models from all perspectives; not only the improvement in students' knowledge of anatomy but also the students' assessment of such models. Here, students of veterinary medicine and animal science evaluated the reproducibility and effectiveness of 3D-printed models as a learning tool by completing our questionnaires, with a focus on their understanding of the skull-morphological differences among dog breeds. With the COVID-19 pandemic having obliged veterinary universities to provide courses online, we also investigated how the pandemic affected the students' evaluation of the 3D-printed models. The questionnaire results revealed that the animal science students were satisfied with the reproducibility of the 3D-printed models, but the veterinary students were not (they preferred to use real specimens). The skull differences were well understood by both types of students, indicating that 3D-printed models are effective for learning about rare skeletal specimens. The veterinary students who experienced the COVID-19 pandemic tended to choose real specimens more often than those who did not have this experience. Our results suggest that the use of 3D-printed models as an introduction and the use of real specimens in anatomy laboratory courses can be adequate for veterinary students. Together our findings suggest ways to improve the educational performance of 3D-printed models for veterinary students who need to understand the anatomy of many species.
骨骼的三维(3D)打印模型是真实骨骼标本方便且耐用的替代品,已在解剖实验室中使用。有必要从各个角度确定3D打印模型的确切优势;不仅要提高学生的解剖学知识,还要了解学生对这类模型的评估。在此,兽医学和动物科学专业的学生通过填写我们的问卷,评估了3D打印模型作为学习工具的可重复性和有效性,重点是他们对不同犬种头骨形态差异的理解。由于新冠疫情迫使兽医大学提供在线课程,我们还调查了疫情如何影响学生对3D打印模型的评估。问卷结果显示,动物科学专业的学生对3D打印模型的可重复性感到满意,但兽医专业的学生不满意(他们更喜欢使用真实标本)。两类学生都很好地理解了头骨差异,这表明3D打印模型对于学习罕见骨骼标本很有效。经历过新冠疫情的兽医专业学生比没有这种经历的学生更倾向于选择真实标本。我们的结果表明,将3D打印模型用作入门工具,并在解剖实验室课程中使用真实标本,对兽医专业学生来说可能是足够的。我们的研究结果共同提出了一些方法,以提高3D打印模型对需要了解多种物种解剖结构的兽医专业学生的教育效果。