Department of Geography and Planning, Queen's University, Kingston, ON, K7L 3N6, Canada.
BMC Prim Care. 2024 Aug 28;25(1):317. doi: 10.1186/s12875-024-02562-7.
The caregiving scholarship widely acknowledges informal caregivers' contributions to maintaining older adults' health and well-being. However, informal caregivers encounter economic, physical, social, financial and psychological challenges when caring for older adults. The caregiving literature has shown variations in caregiving intensity and motivation between rural and urban informal caregivers of older adults. This situation is likely to result in rural-urban disparities in caregiver burden. However, the literature on predictors of caregiver burden is more focused on demographic, socio-economic, caregiving and health-related factors with very little attention to geographical dynamics. For this reason, the effects of demographic, socio-economic, caregiving, and health-related factors on the variations in caregiver burden between rural and urban informal caregivers of older adults are yet to be known in the sub-Saharan African context, including Ghana. Notably, the impact of geographical location on caregiver burden is mainly missing in the informal caregiving literature in Ghana. Situated within the stress process model, we determine the association between geographical location and caregiver burden among informal caregivers of older adults in Ghana.
This study employed data from a large cross-sectional survey on informal caregiving, health, and healthcare among caregivers of older adults aged 50 years or above (N = 1,853) in Ghana. We selected the World Health Organization Impact of Caregiving Scale to measure caregiver burden. Generalized multivariable linear regression models were employed to determine the association between geographical location and caregiver burden among informal caregivers of older adults. We reported beta values and standard errors with significance levels of 0.05 or less.
The results showed that rural informal caregivers of older adults significantly have a decreased caregiver burden compared to urban informal caregivers (β = -1.64; SE = 0.41). Also, participants across all the self-rated health categories (poor/very poor: β = 12.63; SE = 1.65; fair: β = 9.56; SE = 1.07; good: β = 11.00; SE = 0.61, very good: β = 7.03; SE = 0.49) have a significantly increased caregiver burden for the full sample and for both rural (poor/very poor: β = 13.88; SE = 2.4; fair: β = 6.11; SE = 1.62; good: β = 9.97; SE = 0.96, very good: β = 6.06; SE = 0.71) and urban (poor/very poor: β = 11.86; SE = 2.25; fair: β = 12.33; SE = 1.42; good: β = 11.80; SE = 0.79, very good: β = 7.90; SE = 0.67) participants. This study further revealed that participants with no financial support needs reported a decreased caregiver burden compared to those with financial support needs for the full sample (β = -2.92, p-value < 0.01) and for both rural (β = -3.20; p-value < 0.01) and urban (β =-2.70; p-value < 0.01) participants.
The findings from this study underscore geographical location differences in caregiver burden among informal caregivers of older adults in Ghana. Given these findings, the need to consider geographical location variations in providing welfare and health support programs to lessen caregiver burden among informal caregivers of older adults is welcomed. In line with the stress process model, such welfare and health programs should consider background, context, and stressor factors that contribute to variations in caregiver burden between rural and urban informal caregivers of older adults in Ghana and other sub-Saharan African countries.
照护研究广泛承认非正式照护者对维持老年人健康和幸福的贡献。然而,当照顾老年人时,非正式照护者会遇到经济、身体、社会、财务和心理方面的挑战。照护文献表明,农村和城市老年人的非正式照护者在照护强度和动机方面存在差异。这种情况可能导致农村和城市地区的照护者负担存在差异。然而,关于照护者负担预测因素的文献更多地关注人口统计学、社会经济、照护和与健康相关的因素,而很少关注地理动态。出于这个原因,在撒哈拉以南非洲地区,包括加纳,农村和城市老年人的非正式照护者的照护者负担差异的人口统计学、社会经济、照护和与健康相关因素的影响仍不清楚。值得注意的是,在加纳的非正式照护文献中,地理位置对照护者负担的影响主要缺失。在压力过程模型的基础上,我们确定了加纳老年人的非正式照护者的地理位置与照护者负担之间的关联。
本研究采用了一项关于加纳 50 岁及以上老年人的非正式照护、健康和医疗保健的大型横断面调查的数据。我们选择世界卫生组织的照护影响量表来衡量照护者负担。采用广义多变量线性回归模型来确定加纳老年人的非正式照护者的地理位置与照护者负担之间的关联。我们报告了β值和标准误差,显著性水平为 0.05 或更低。
结果表明,与城市非正式照护者相比,农村非正式照护者的照护者负担显著降低(β=-1.64;SE=0.41)。此外,所有自我报告的健康类别(差/非常差:β=12.63;SE=1.65;一般:β=9.56;SE=1.07;良好:β=11.00;SE=0.61,非常好:β=7.03;SE=0.49)的参与者的照护者负担都显著增加,包括全样本和农村(差/非常差:β=13.88;SE=2.4;一般:β=6.11;SE=1.62;良好:β=9.97;SE=0.96,非常好:β=6.06;SE=0.71)和城市(差/非常差:β=11.86;SE=2.25;一般:β=12.33;SE=1.42;良好:β=11.80;SE=0.79,非常好:β=7.90;SE=0.67)参与者。本研究进一步表明,没有财务支持需求的参与者的照护者负担比有财务支持需求的参与者负担减轻,包括全样本(β=-2.92,p 值<0.01)和农村(β=-3.20;p 值<0.01)和城市(β=-2.70;p 值<0.01)参与者。
这项研究的结果强调了加纳老年人的非正式照护者的照护者负担存在地理位置差异。鉴于这些发现,需要考虑在提供福利和健康支持计划方面考虑地理位置的差异,以减轻加纳和其他撒哈拉以南非洲国家的非正式照护者的照护者负担。根据压力过程模型,这些福利和健康计划应考虑导致加纳农村和城市老年人的非正式照护者的照护者负担差异的背景、环境和压力源因素。