MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 Oct;358:117092. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117092. Epub 2024 Jul 11.
Sexual harassment in secondary school is common but only recently acknowledged as a widespread problem in the United Kingdom. There is limited research on how schools respond to incidents of sexual harassment. The aim of this study was to understand how school systems shape the dynamics of disclosure, reporting and handling of sexual harassment in school (including behaviours, processes, norms), and to identify opportunities for effecting systems change.
We used participatory systems mapping to elicit school stakeholders' perspectives on systems factors and their connections. Researchers built the map based on in-person workshops with students (n = 18) and staff (n = 4) from three schools in Scotland. Survey data (n = 638 students; n = 119 staff) was used to augment participant perspectives. The map was validated via three workshops (two online, one in-person) involving students and staff from seven schools.
The final map (causal loop diagram) represents a hypothesised system of 25 causally connected factors and three feedback loops shaping the disclosure, reporting and handling of sexual harassment. We grouped these factors into four interlinked themes: 1] Knowledge and confidence; 2] Trust in reporting system and processes; 3] Communication, confidentiality and safeguarding; and, 4] Prioritisation of sexual harassment.
This study highlights the interconnectedness of factors shaping disclosure, reporting and handling of sexual harassment within secondary schools. The map surfaces key challenges for schools and provides a foundation for learning and discussions on where to focus efforts in future.
中学性骚扰很常见,但直到最近才被承认为英国的一个普遍问题。关于学校如何应对性骚扰事件的研究有限。本研究旨在了解学校系统如何塑造性骚扰在学校(包括行为、过程、规范)中的披露、报告和处理动态,并确定进行系统变革的机会。
我们使用参与式系统映射来引出学校利益相关者对系统因素及其联系的看法。研究人员根据来自苏格兰三所学校的学生(n=18)和工作人员(n=4)的实地研讨会构建了该地图。调查数据(n=638 名学生;n=119 名工作人员)用于补充参与者的观点。该地图通过涉及来自七所学校的学生和工作人员的三个研讨会(两个在线,一个面对面)进行了验证。
最终地图(因果关系图)代表了一个假设的系统,其中包含 25 个因果相关的因素和三个反馈回路,这些因素塑造了性骚扰的披露、报告和处理。我们将这些因素分为四个相互关联的主题:1)知识和信心;2)对报告系统和流程的信任;3)沟通、保密性和保障;以及,4)性骚扰的优先事项。
本研究强调了塑造中学性骚扰披露、报告和处理的因素之间的相互关联性。该地图揭示了学校面临的主要挑战,并为未来的学习和讨论提供了一个基础,了解应在哪些方面集中精力。