Williams Brogan, Gichard Luke, Johnson David, Louis Matthew
Department of Research, College of Functional Movement Clinicians, Auckland, New Zealand.
Department of Research and Neurosurgery, The Back Pain and Functional Movement Training Centre, Brisbane, Australia.
J Clin Imaging Sci. 2024 Aug 1;14:28. doi: 10.25259/JCIS_68_2024. eCollection 2024.
Many chiropractors use radiological imaging, particularly X-rays, to locate and diagnose the cause of their patients' pain. However, this approach is fundamentally flawed because X-rays provide anatomical information but not functional insights. Pain, tissue damage, and injury do not always correlate directly with X-ray appearances. Given the high incidence of abnormalities found in X-rays of asymptomatic patients, the diagnostic validity of X-rays can be questioned, especially when used in isolation of the patient's history and/or a proper clinical assessment. One may posit that their application promotes overdiagnosis, and unvalidated treatment of X-ray findings (such as changes in postural curvature), which may mislead patients into believing these changes are directly responsible for their pain. A substantial amount of research has shown that there is no association between pain and reversed cervical curves. X-ray accuracy can vary due to several factors, including patient positioning, physical and morphological changes, interreliability among doctors, and other influences such as stress, pain, and emotional state. Over the past two decades, medical boards and health associations worldwide have made significant efforts to communicate better when imaging is necessary, focusing on reducing radiographic imaging. This review describes concerns about the frequent, almost routine use of spinal X-rays in primary care for spine-related pain in the absence of red-flag clinical signs.
许多脊椎按摩师使用放射成像,尤其是X射线,来定位和诊断患者疼痛的原因。然而,这种方法存在根本缺陷,因为X射线提供的是解剖学信息而非功能方面的见解。疼痛、组织损伤和伤痛并不总是与X射线表现直接相关。鉴于在无症状患者的X射线检查中发现异常的发生率很高,X射线的诊断有效性可能会受到质疑,尤其是在脱离患者病史和/或适当临床评估单独使用时。有人可能会认为,其应用会导致过度诊断以及对X射线检查结果(如姿势曲率变化)进行未经证实的治疗,这可能会误导患者认为这些变化是其疼痛的直接原因。大量研究表明,疼痛与颈椎曲线反弓之间没有关联。由于多种因素,包括患者体位、身体和形态变化、医生之间的可靠性以及压力、疼痛和情绪状态等其他影响,X射线的准确性可能会有所不同。在过去二十年中,全球各地的医学委员会和健康协会都在大力努力,在必要进行成像检查时更好地进行沟通,重点是减少放射成像。这篇综述描述了在缺乏警示临床体征的情况下,在基层医疗中频繁甚至几乎常规地使用脊柱X射线来诊断脊柱相关疼痛所引发的问题。