Perelli-Harris Brienna, Gerber Theodore, Hilevych Yuliya
University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
University of Wisconsin, Madison, USA.
Eur J Popul. 2024 Sep 10;40(1):28. doi: 10.1007/s10680-024-09713-7.
While uncertainty has been a key explanation for very low fertility throughout Europe, few studies have analysed how macro-level uncertainty trickles down to shape how people think about having children. Most research focuses on economic uncertainty, not political or social uncertainty. We address these gaps with qualitative data from Ukraine, which has experienced extreme political uncertainty and, for the past decade, armed conflict. Ukraine also had exceptionally low fertility, with an estimated total fertility rate of 1.17 in 2021. In July 2021, we conducted 16 online focus groups on topics related to childbearing with informants living in urban and rural areas in Eastern Ukraine, including areas of Donetsk province that were outside Ukrainian government control. Half the groups consisted of persons displaced by the 2014 Donbas war. The discussions revealed distinct patterns whereby experiences of displacement, the simmering armed conflict, and economic problems combined to produce and intensify uncertainties that discouraged couples from having more than one child. Some blamed the government or delved into conspiracy theories. Armed conflict generates its own forms of uncertainty that interact with persistent economic challenges, dampening fertility.
虽然不确定性一直是整个欧洲生育率极低的关键解释,但很少有研究分析宏观层面的不确定性是如何逐渐影响人们对生育的看法的。大多数研究关注的是经济不确定性,而非政治或社会不确定性。我们利用来自乌克兰的定性数据填补这些空白,乌克兰经历了极端的政治不确定性,并且在过去十年中一直处于武装冲突之中。乌克兰的生育率也异常低,2021年估计总和生育率为1.17。2021年7月,我们针对与生育相关的主题开展了16次在线焦点小组讨论,受访者来自乌克兰东部的城乡地区,包括顿涅茨克省不受乌克兰政府控制的地区。其中一半的小组由因2014年顿巴斯战争而流离失所的人员组成。讨论揭示了不同的模式,即流离失所经历、持续的武装冲突和经济问题共同导致并加剧了不确定性,使夫妇不愿生育超过一个孩子。一些人指责政府,或陷入阴谋论。武装冲突产生了其自身形式的不确定性,这些不确定性与持续的经济挑战相互作用,抑制了生育率。