Snider D E, Kelly G D, Cauthen G M, Thompson N J, Kilburn J O
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1985 Jul;132(1):125-32. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1985.132.1.125.
Three hundred ninety-eight tuberculosis patients with tubercle bacilli resistant to isoniazid and/or streptomycin were matched by age, race, sex, and geographic area to an equal number of patients with tubercle bacilli susceptible to 9 drugs, including isoniazid and streptomycin, in an effort to determine whether the risk of infection and disease among contacts of patients with resistant bacilli is different from the risk among contacts to patients with susceptible bacilli. The risk of infection among contacts of previously untreated patients was not significantly different, regardless of whether the bacilli were drug-resistant or susceptible. However, the risk of infection increased if the index patient with resistant bacilli had been previously treated. We found no evidence of a lower risk of infection among contacts exposed to bacilli resistant to the highest concentration of isoniazid tested or among contacts exposed to bacilli resistant to both isoniazid and streptomycin. There was a strong association between infection risk among contacts and the age of the index case; younger patients were more infectious. Index cases tended to infect most (or all) or few (or none) of their contacts. The investigation of contacts of patients excreting drug-resistant bacilli should be given high priority.
398例对异烟肼和/或链霉素耐药的结核杆菌患者,按照年龄、种族、性别和地理区域,与同等数量的对包括异烟肼和链霉素在内的9种药物敏感的结核杆菌患者进行匹配,以确定耐药杆菌患者的接触者中感染和发病风险是否与敏感杆菌患者的接触者中的风险不同。无论杆菌是耐药还是敏感,既往未治疗患者的接触者中的感染风险没有显著差异。然而,如果耐药杆菌的索引患者曾接受过治疗,感染风险会增加。我们没有发现证据表明,接触对测试的最高浓度异烟肼耐药的杆菌的接触者,或接触对异烟肼和链霉素均耐药的杆菌的接触者,感染风险较低。接触者中的感染风险与索引病例的年龄之间存在很强的关联;年轻患者传染性更强。索引病例倾向于感染其大多数(或全部)或少数(或没有)接触者。对排出耐药杆菌患者的接触者进行调查应给予高度优先考虑。