Fu Yan, Zhang Yuxin, Ye Bing, Babineau Jessica, Zhao Yan, Gao Zhengke, Mihailidis Alex
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
KITE - Toronto Rehabilitation Institute, University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Sep 16;26:e51564. doi: 10.2196/51564.
BACKGROUND: Hand function assessment heavily relies on specific task scenarios, making it challenging to ensure validity and reliability. In addition, the wide range of assessment tools, limited and expensive data recording, and analysis systems further aggravate the issue. However, smartphones provide a promising opportunity to address these challenges. Thus, the built-in, high-efficiency sensors in smartphones can be used as effective tools for hand function assessment. OBJECTIVE: This review aims to evaluate existing studies on hand function evaluation using smartphones. METHODS: An information specialist searched 8 databases on June 8, 2023. The search criteria included two major concepts: (1) smartphone or mobile phone or mHealth and (2) hand function or function assessment. Searches were limited to human studies in the English language and excluded conference proceedings and trial register records. Two reviewers independently screened all studies, with a third reviewer involved in resolving discrepancies. The included studies were rated according to the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool. One reviewer extracted data on publication, demographics, hand function types, sensors used for hand function assessment, and statistical or machine learning (ML) methods. Accuracy was checked by another reviewer. The data were synthesized and tabulated based on each of the research questions. RESULTS: In total, 46 studies were included. Overall, 11 types of hand dysfunction-related problems were identified, such as Parkinson disease, wrist injury, stroke, and hand injury, and 6 types of hand dysfunctions were found, namely an abnormal range of motion, tremors, bradykinesia, the decline of fine motor skills, hypokinesia, and nonspecific dysfunction related to hand arthritis. Among all built-in smartphone sensors, the accelerometer was the most used, followed by the smartphone camera. Most studies used statistical methods for data processing, whereas ML algorithms were applied for disease detection, disease severity evaluation, disease prediction, and feature aggregation. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review highlights the potential of smartphone-based hand function assessment. The review suggests that a smartphone is a promising tool for hand function evaluation. ML is a conducive method to classify levels of hand dysfunction. Future research could (1) explore a gold standard for smartphone-based hand function assessment and (2) take advantage of smartphones' multiple built-in sensors to assess hand function comprehensively, focus on developing ML methods for processing collected smartphone data, and focus on real-time assessment during rehabilitation training. The limitations of the research are 2-fold. First, the nascent nature of smartphone-based hand function assessment led to limited relevant literature, affecting the evidence's completeness and comprehensiveness. This can hinder supporting viewpoints and drawing conclusions. Second, literature quality varies due to the exploratory nature of the topic, with potential inconsistencies and a lack of high-quality reference studies and meta-analyses.
背景:手部功能评估严重依赖于特定的任务场景,这使得确保有效性和可靠性具有挑战性。此外,评估工具种类繁多、数据记录有限且昂贵以及分析系统进一步加剧了这一问题。然而,智能手机为应对这些挑战提供了一个有前景的机会。因此,智能手机中内置的高效传感器可用作手部功能评估的有效工具。 目的:本综述旨在评估使用智能手机进行手部功能评估的现有研究。 方法:一名信息专家于2023年6月8日检索了8个数据库。检索标准包括两个主要概念:(1)智能手机或移动电话或移动健康,以及(2)手部功能或功能评估。检索限于英文的人体研究,排除会议论文集和试验注册记录。两名评审员独立筛选所有研究,第三名评审员参与解决分歧。纳入的研究根据混合方法评估工具进行评分。一名评审员提取关于发表情况、人口统计学、手部功能类型、用于手部功能评估的传感器以及统计或机器学习(ML)方法的数据。另一名评审员检查准确性。根据每个研究问题对数据进行综合和制表。 结果:总共纳入了46项研究。总体而言,确定了11种与手部功能障碍相关的问题,如帕金森病、手腕损伤、中风和手部损伤,还发现了6种手部功能障碍,即运动范围异常、震颤、运动迟缓、精细运动技能下降、运动减退以及与手部关节炎相关的非特异性功能障碍。在所有内置智能手机传感器中,加速度计使用最为频繁,其次是智能手机摄像头。大多数研究使用统计方法进行数据处理,而ML算法则应用于疾病检测、疾病严重程度评估、疾病预测和特征聚合。 结论:本系统综述突出了基于智能手机的手部功能评估的潜力。该综述表明智能手机是手部功能评估的一个有前景的工具。ML是一种有助于对手部功能障碍水平进行分类的方法。未来的研究可以(1)探索基于智能手机的手部功能评估的金标准,以及(2)利用智能手机的多个内置传感器全面评估手部功能,专注于开发用于处理收集到的智能手机数据的ML方法,并专注于康复训练期间的实时评估。该研究的局限性有两方面。首先,基于智能手机的手部功能评估尚处于初期阶段,导致相关文献有限,影响了证据的完整性和全面性。这可能会阻碍支持观点和得出结论。其次,由于该主题的探索性质,文献质量参差不齐,可能存在不一致之处,并且缺乏高质量的参考研究和荟萃分析。
J Med Internet Res. 2024-9-16
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2016-4
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2021-4-19
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015-7-27
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015-6-23
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-8-14
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2017-12-22
Wiley Interdiscip Rev Data Min Knowl Discov. 2023
Front Psychiatry. 2023-2-23
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2022-5-9