Department of Medical Oncology, Sidney Kimmel Cancer Center, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Department of Epidemiology, Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health and Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Sep 18;24(1):2533. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-20008-8.
Black men consistently have higher rates of prostate cancer (PCA)- related mortality. Advances in PCA treatment, screening, and hereditary cancer assessment center around germline testing (GT). Of concern is the significant under-engagement of Black males in PCA GT, limiting the benefit of precision therapy and tailored cancer screening despite longstanding awareness of these disparities. To address these critical disparities, the Socioecological Model (SEM) was employed to develop comprehensive recommendations to overcome barriers and implement equitable strategies to engage Black males in PCA GT.
Clinical/research experts, national organization leaders, and community stakeholders spanning multiple regions in US and Africa participated in developing a framework for equity in PCA GT grounded in the SEM. A novel mixed-methods approach was employed to generate key areas to be addressed and informed statements for consensus consideration utilizing the modified Delphi model. Statements achieving strong consensus (> =75% agreement) were included in final equity frameworks addressing clinical/community engagement and research engagement.
All societal levels of the SEM (interpersonal, institutional, community, and policy/advocacy) must deliver information about PCA GT to Black males that address benefits/limitations, clinical impact, hereditary cancer implications, with acknowledgment of mistrust (mean scores [MS] 4.57-5.00). Interpersonal strategies for information delivery included engagement of family/friends/peers/Black role models to improve education/awareness and overcome mistrust (MS 4.65-5.00). Institutional strategies included diversifying clinical, research, and educational programs and integrating community liaisons into healthcare institutions (MS 4.57-5.00). Community strategies included partnerships with healthcare institutions and visibility of healthcare providers/researchers at community events (MS 4.65-4.91). Policy/advocacy included improving partnerships between advocacy and healthcare/community organizations while protecting patient benefits (MS 4.57-5.00). Media strategies were endorsed for the first time at every level (MS 4.56-5.00).
The SEM-based equity frameworks proposed provide the first multidisciplinary strategies dedicated to increase engagement of Black males in PCA GT, which are critical to reduce disparities in PCA-mortality through informing tailored screening, targeted therapy, and cascade testing in families.
黑人男性前列腺癌(PCA)相关死亡率一直较高。PCA 治疗、筛查和遗传性癌症评估的进展都围绕着种系测试(GT)展开。令人担忧的是,黑人男性参与 PCA GT 的比例严重不足,尽管人们早就意识到了这些差异,但这限制了精准治疗和量身定制的癌症筛查的益处。为了解决这些关键的差异,采用社会生态学模型(SEM)制定了全面的建议,以克服障碍并实施公平的策略,使黑人男性参与 PCA GT。
跨越美国和非洲多个地区的临床/研究专家、国家组织领导人和社区利益攸关方参与制定了一个基于 SEM 的 PCA GT 公平框架。采用一种新颖的混合方法,利用改良 Delphi 模型生成需要解决的关键领域和共识考虑的陈述。达成强烈共识(>75%的一致性)的陈述被纳入最终的公平框架,以解决临床/社区参与和研究参与的问题。
SEM 的所有社会层面(人际、机构、社区和政策/倡导)都必须向黑人男性提供有关 PCA GT 的信息,其中包括益处/局限性、临床影响、遗传性癌症影响,并承认不信任(平均得分[MS]4.57-5.00)。人际层面的信息传递策略包括让家人/朋友/同伴/黑人榜样参与进来,以提高教育/意识并克服不信任(MS 4.65-5.00)。机构层面的策略包括多样化临床、研究和教育项目,并将社区联络人纳入医疗机构(MS 4.57-5.00)。社区层面的策略包括与医疗机构建立伙伴关系,并在社区活动中展示医疗服务提供者/研究人员(MS 4.65-4.91)。政策/倡导层面包括改善倡导组织与医疗/社区组织之间的伙伴关系,同时保护患者利益(MS 4.57-5.00)。媒体策略首次在各个层面得到认可(MS 4.56-5.00)。
基于 SEM 的公平框架提供了首批专门用于增加黑人男性参与 PCA GT 的多学科策略,这对于通过告知量身定制的筛查、靶向治疗和家族中的级联测试来减少 PCA 死亡率方面的差异至关重要。