Gallery E D, Ross M R, Gyory A Z
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1985 Aug 31;291(6495):563-6. doi: 10.1136/bmj.291.6495.563.
One hundred and eighty three hypertensive pregnant women were randomly assigned to antihypertensive treatment with oxprenolol (96 women) or methyldopa (87 women). Control of hypertension was equivalent in both treatment groups, and in 64 (35%) cases hydralazine had to be added to the treatment to achieve the therapeutic goal (diastolic blood pressure below 85 mm Hg). Five perinatal deaths occurred, one in the oxprenolol group and four in the methyldopa group. Detailed analysis confirmed a previous report of greater fetal growth in the group treated with oxprenolol; this trend was present regardless of severity of hypertension and parity. With increasing duration of treatment the differences between the two groups diminished, and there was no difference after 10 weeks of treatment, a finding that may explain some of the reported discrepancies among therapeutic studies. As hypertension in pregnancy may pursue an accelerated course, necessitating urgent delivery, and there is no satisfactory method of predicting the duration of treatment in individual patients fetal benefit is most likely to be achieved by treatment with oxprenolol, provided that there is no maternal contraindication to treatment with beta blockers.
183名高血压孕妇被随机分为两组,分别接受氧烯洛尔治疗(96名妇女)或甲基多巴治疗(87名妇女)。两个治疗组的高血压控制效果相当,在64例(35%)病例中,必须添加肼屈嗪才能达到治疗目标(舒张压低于85毫米汞柱)。发生了5例围产期死亡,氧烯洛尔组1例,甲基多巴组4例。详细分析证实了先前的一份报告,即接受氧烯洛尔治疗的组中胎儿生长更好;无论高血压严重程度和产次如何,这种趋势都存在。随着治疗时间的延长,两组之间的差异减小,治疗10周后没有差异,这一发现可能解释了治疗研究中报告的一些差异。由于妊娠期高血压可能呈加速发展,需要紧急分娩,而且没有令人满意的方法预测个体患者的治疗持续时间,因此,如果没有使用β受体阻滞剂治疗的母体禁忌证,使用氧烯洛尔治疗最有可能使胎儿受益。