Gotti David, Morales Ernesto, Routhier François, Riendeau Jonathan, Hadj Hassen Ahmed
School of Rehabilitation Sciences, Laval University, Québec City, QC, Canada.
Centre for Interdisciplinary Research in Rehabilitation and Social Integration, Centre Intégré Universitaire de Santé et de Services Sociaux de la Capitale-Nationale du Québec, Québec City, QC, Canada.
Front Rehabil Sci. 2024 Aug 27;5:1305191. doi: 10.3389/fresc.2024.1305191. eCollection 2024.
Worldwide, one in six individuals live with a disability. Many people continue to experience disabling situations, particularly when travelling. Travel can be an important part of the lives of many people, including people with disabilities. Barriers to accessing air travel can lead to a reluctance to travel for these potential passengers. As early as the flight planning stage, options to facilitate accessibility are limited. At airports, passengers must travel long distances in areas where navigation is complex, and accessibility limited. Furthermore, few aircraft are accessible. The travel experience can have adverse effects on the health of people with disabilities. Practices are sometimes not inclusive, not always available, and may not address the full spectrum of possible needs. The objective of this study is to provide a state of art on accessibility features available to people with disabilities in the busiest international airports.
A scoping review of practices in airport accessibility was done. A search strategy was deployed in 4 databases (Avery index to architectural periodicals, Medline, CINAHL, and Web of science). The official websites of the 35 busiest airports were exhaustively consulted. All information regarding accessibility measures and inclusive services were extracted.
31 scientific articles, out of 3,640 screened, and all extracted data from airports' website were considered for synthesis. While efforts are made in major airports, there is a great inconsistency in accessibility features. Both facilitators and challenges are encountered by people with disabilities at every stage of air travel. These stages include journey planning; getting to and from the airport, obtain human assistance, navigate in the premises, check in, security screening, using facilities, boarding and disembarking, customs and immigration procedures, and luggage management.
Services need to be extensively planned, placing a significant burden on passengers. The disability-centric perspective disregard passengers' unique needs and capabilities, leading to a sense of dehumanization. The complexity of airport organizations, shared responsibilities, limited communication, training challenges can deter accessibility initiatives and create discomfort during travel. This study is the first step of a broader project supported by Canadian Accessibility Standards, focusing on enhancing inclusive accessibility in Canadian airports.
在全球范围内,六分之一的人患有残疾。许多人继续面临致残的情况,尤其是在旅行时。旅行可以是许多人生活的重要组成部分,包括残疾人。航空旅行的障碍可能导致这些潜在乘客不愿出行。早在航班规划阶段,便于出行的选择就很有限。在机场,乘客必须在导航复杂且无障碍设施有限的区域长途跋涉。此外,可供残疾人使用的飞机很少。旅行经历可能会对残疾人的健康产生不利影响。相关做法有时不具包容性,并非随时可用,而且可能无法满足所有可能的需求。本研究的目的是介绍最繁忙的国际机场为残疾人提供的无障碍设施现状。
对机场无障碍设施的相关做法进行了范围综述。在4个数据库(《建筑期刊艾弗里索引》、医学数据库、护理学与健康领域数据库、科学网)中部署了检索策略。对35个最繁忙机场的官方网站进行了详尽查询。提取了所有关于无障碍措施和包容性服务的信息。
在筛选的3640篇科学文章中,有31篇被纳入考虑进行综合分析,同时还考虑了从机场网站提取的所有数据。虽然主要机场都在努力,但无障碍设施存在很大差异。残疾人在航空旅行的每个阶段都会遇到便利因素和挑战。这些阶段包括行程规划;往返机场、获得人工协助、在候机楼内导航、办理登机手续、安全检查、使用设施、登机和下机、海关和移民手续以及行李管理。
服务需要进行广泛规划,给乘客带来了沉重负担。以残疾人为中心的视角忽视了乘客的独特需求和能力,导致一种不人性化的感觉。机场组织的复杂性、责任分担、沟通有限、培训挑战可能会阻碍无障碍设施建设举措,并在旅行期间造成不便。本研究是由加拿大无障碍标准支持的一个更广泛项目的第一步,该项目侧重于提高加拿大机场的包容性无障碍水平。