Urbanczik R
Zentralbl Bakteriol Mikrobiol Hyg A. 1985 Aug;260(1):81-7. doi: 10.1016/s0176-6724(85)80101-2.
The relative merits of microscopy and culture are discussed; it is attempted to review the possible reasons why microscopy is considered as unreliable in TB diagnosis, including the probably false application of Bayes' theorem. In the author's opinion, microscopy still holds a firm position in the rapid and relatively reliable detection of pulmonary TB. As for culture, it is highly questionable if "better media" could accelerate the growth rate of tubercle bacilli. Therefore, it should be attempted to introduce novel techniques which will allow to decrease considerably the mycobacterial mass needed for detection. Laboratories equipped with such devices could offer their services even on an intercontinental basis, in order to have a favourable cost-benefit ratio.
讨论了显微镜检查和培养的相对优点;试图回顾显微镜检查在结核病诊断中被认为不可靠的可能原因,包括贝叶斯定理可能被错误应用。作者认为,显微镜检查在肺结核的快速且相对可靠的检测中仍占有稳固地位。至于培养,“更好的培养基”是否能加快结核杆菌的生长速度非常值得怀疑。因此,应尝试引入新技术,以大幅减少检测所需的分枝杆菌量。配备此类设备的实验室甚至可以在洲际范围内提供服务,以获得良好的成本效益比。