Rosina Robyn, McMaster Rose, Lovecchio Victoria, Wu Chiung-Jung
Independent Researcher, Sydney, Australia.
Infant, Child, Youth and Family Mental Health Service, Western New South Wales Local Health District, Orange, Australia.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2025 Feb;34(1):e13439. doi: 10.1111/inm.13439. Epub 2024 Sep 27.
To critically synthesise the literature on the lived experience of young adults about their transition to adult mental health services including the perspectives of key people in their world: parents, carers and clinicians. Young people within child and adolescent mental health services are usually required to transition to adult mental health services at the age of 18, despite evidence showing cognitive and emotional development impacted by childhood trauma, illness and adverse life events. This qualitative systematic review searched relevant electronic databases, policy documents, grey literature and theses examining original qualitative peer-reviewed studies published from 2009 to 2022 in English. The process utilised the PRISMA guidelines and the quality of papers assessed by the JBI critical appraisal tool. Nine papers met the criteria for inclusion in the review. The results indicate that qualitative research listening to the voices of young people transitioning to adult mental health services is a rarity. Even fewer papers examine the perspectives of key people in their lives: this review has critically synthesised the literature on the lived experience of young adults about their transition to adult mental health services including the perspectives of key people in their world: parents, carers and clinicians. The main themes identified include: age 18 is not a helpful trigger to transition; young people want more individualised planning; parents want more involvement and clinicians open up about a challenging nexus with adult mental health services.
批判性地综合有关年轻人向成人心理健康服务过渡的生活经历的文献,包括他们生活中关键人物的观点:父母、照顾者和临床医生。儿童和青少年心理健康服务机构中的年轻人通常在18岁时需要过渡到成人心理健康服务,尽管有证据表明童年创伤、疾病和不良生活事件会影响认知和情感发展。这项定性系统综述检索了相关电子数据库、政策文件、灰色文献和论文,以研究2009年至2022年以英文发表的原创定性同行评审研究。该过程采用了PRISMA指南,并通过JBI批判性评价工具评估论文质量。九篇论文符合纳入综述的标准。结果表明,听取向成人心理健康服务过渡的年轻人声音的定性研究很少见。更少的论文探讨了他们生活中关键人物的观点:本综述批判性地综合了有关年轻人向成人心理健康服务过渡的生活经历的文献,包括他们生活中关键人物的观点:父母、照顾者和临床医生。确定的主要主题包括:18岁不是过渡的有益触发因素;年轻人希望有更个性化的规划;父母希望更多地参与,临床医生公开谈论与成人心理健康服务的具有挑战性的联系。