Jang Hyunwoo, Dai Rui, Mashour George A, Hudetz Anthony G, Huang Zirui
Neuroscience Graduate Program, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Center for Consciousness Science, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Brain Sci. 2024 Aug 30;14(9):880. doi: 10.3390/brainsci14090880.
Accurate and generalizable classification of brain states is essential for understanding their neural underpinnings and improving clinical diagnostics. Traditionally, functional connectivity patterns and graph-theoretic metrics have been utilized. However, cortical gradient features, which reflect global brain organization, offer a complementary approach. We hypothesized that a machine learning model integrating these three feature sets would effectively discriminate between baseline and atypical brain states across a wide spectrum of conditions, even though the underlying neural mechanisms vary. To test this, we extracted features from brain states associated with three meta-conditions including unconsciousness (NREM2 sleep, propofol deep sedation, and propofol general anesthesia), psychedelic states induced by hallucinogens (subanesthetic ketamine, lysergic acid diethylamide, and nitrous oxide), and neuropsychiatric disorders (attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia). We used support vector machine with nested cross-validation to construct our models. The soft voting ensemble model marked the average balanced accuracy (average of specificity and sensitivity) of 79% (62-98% across all conditions), outperforming individual base models (70-76%). Notably, our models exhibited varying degrees of transferability across different datasets, with performance being dependent on the specific brain states and feature sets used. Feature importance analysis across meta-conditions suggests that the underlying neural mechanisms vary significantly, necessitating tailored approaches for accurate classification of specific brain states. This finding underscores the value of our feature-integrated ensemble models, which leverage the strengths of multiple feature types to achieve robust performance across a broader range of brain states. While our approach offers valuable insights into the neural signatures of different brain states, future work is needed to develop and validate even more generalizable models that can accurately classify brain states across a wider array of conditions.
准确且可推广的脑状态分类对于理解其神经基础和改善临床诊断至关重要。传统上,人们利用功能连接模式和图论指标。然而,反映全脑组织的皮质梯度特征提供了一种补充方法。我们假设,一个整合这三种特征集的机器学习模型能够有效区分广泛条件下的基线脑状态和非典型脑状态,尽管潜在的神经机制各不相同。为了验证这一点,我们从与三种元条件相关的脑状态中提取特征,这三种元条件包括无意识状态(快速眼动睡眠2期、丙泊酚深度镇静和丙泊酚全身麻醉)、致幻剂诱导的迷幻状态(亚麻醉剂量氯胺酮、麦角酸二乙胺和一氧化二氮)以及神经精神疾病(注意力缺陷多动障碍、双相情感障碍和精神分裂症)。我们使用带有嵌套交叉验证的支持向量机来构建模型。软投票集成模型的平均平衡准确率(特异性和敏感性的平均值)为79%(在所有条件下为62 - 98%),优于单个基础模型(70 - 76%)。值得注意的是,我们的模型在不同数据集上表现出不同程度的可转移性,其性能取决于所使用的特定脑状态和特征集。跨元条件的特征重要性分析表明,潜在的神经机制差异显著,因此需要针对特定脑状态的准确分类采用量身定制的方法。这一发现强调了我们的特征集成集成模型(feature-integrated ensemble models)的价值,该模型利用多种特征类型的优势,在更广泛的脑状态范围内实现稳健性能。虽然我们的方法为不同脑状态的神经特征提供了有价值的见解,但未来还需要开展工作来开发和验证更具可推广性的模型,以便能够在更广泛的条件下准确分类脑状态。