Wong Michelle, Choi Koeun, Barak Libby, Lapidow Elizabeth, Austin Jennifer, Shafto Patrick, Bonawitz Elizabeth
Graduate School of Education, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
Department of Human Development and Family Science, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA.
Behav Sci (Basel). 2024 Aug 27;14(9):754. doi: 10.3390/bs14090754.
Question asking is a prevalent aspect of children's speech, providing a means by which young learners can rapidly gain information about the world. Previous research has demonstrated that children exhibit sensitivity to the knowledge state of potential informants in laboratory settings. However, it remains unclear whether and how young children are inclined to direct questions that support learning deeper content to more knowledgeable informants in naturalistic classroom contexts. In this study, we examined children's question-asking targets (adults, other preschoolers, self-talk) during an open-play period in a US preschool classroom and assessed how the cognitive and linguistic characteristics of questions varied as a function of the intended recipient. Further, we examined how these patterns changed with age. We recorded the spontaneous speech of individual children between the ages of 3 and 6 years ( = 30, totaling 2875 utterances) in 40-min open-period sessions in their preschool day, noting whether the speech was directed toward an adult, another child, or was stated to self. We publish this fully transcribed database with contextual and linguistic details coded as open access to all future researchers. We found that questions accounted for a greater proportion of preschoolers' adult-directed speech than of their child-directed and self-directed speech, with a particular increase in questions that supported broader learning goals when directed to an adult. Younger children directed a higher proportion of learning questions to adults than themselves, whereas older children asked similar proportions of questions to both, suggesting a difference in younger and older children's question-asking strategies. Although children used greater lexical diversity in questions than in other utterances, their question formulation in terms of length and diversity remained consistent across age and recipient types, reflecting their general linguistic abilities. Our findings reveal that children discriminately choose "what" and "whom" to ask in daily spontaneous conversations. Even in less-structured school contexts, preschoolers direct questions to the informant most likely to be able to provide an adequate answer.
提问是儿童言语中普遍存在的一个方面,它为幼儿提供了一种快速获取有关世界信息的方式。先前的研究表明,儿童在实验室环境中对潜在信息提供者的知识状态表现出敏感性。然而,在自然主义的课堂环境中,幼儿是否以及如何倾向于将支持学习更深入内容的问题指向知识更丰富的信息提供者,这一点仍不清楚。在本研究中,我们在美国一所幼儿园教室的自由玩耍期间,考察了儿童的提问对象(成人、其他学龄前儿童、自言自语),并评估了问题的认知和语言特征如何随预期接受者的不同而变化。此外,我们还考察了这些模式如何随年龄变化。我们记录了3至6岁儿童(n = 30,共2875条话语)在幼儿园一天中40分钟自由活动期间的自发言语,记录这些言语是指向成人、另一个孩子还是自言自语。我们将这个完整转录的数据库以及编码后的上下文和语言细节作为开放获取资源发布,供所有未来的研究人员使用。我们发现,与指向儿童和指向自己的言语相比,问题在学龄前儿童指向成人的言语中所占比例更大,当指向成人时,支持更广泛学习目标的问题尤其有所增加。年幼儿童向成人提出的学习问题比例高于向自己提出的,而年长儿童向两者提出的问题比例相似,这表明年幼儿童和年长儿童在提问策略上存在差异。尽管儿童在问题中使用的词汇比在其他话语中更加多样,但他们在问题表述的长度和多样性方面在不同年龄和接受者类型中保持一致,这反映了他们的一般语言能力。我们的研究结果表明,儿童在日常自发对话中会有区别地选择“什么”和“谁”来提问。即使在结构较松散的学校环境中,学龄前儿童也会将问题指向最有可能提供充分答案的信息提供者。