Higgins Zoe E, Lefebvre Pascal
Department of Kinesiology and Health Sciences, Laurentian University, Sudbury, Ontario, Canada.
Aust J Rural Health. 2024 Dec;32(6):1100-1117. doi: 10.1111/ajr.13188. Epub 2024 Sep 29.
Indigenous children may be at higher risk of being misdiagnosed with speech-language difficulties due to Eurocentric practices in health care and education. The use of conventional speech pathology assessment practices contributes to inappropriate disorder identification, further stigmatising a vulnerable population. Few resources are available for speech pathologists, which examine the cultural and linguistic relevance of assessments for this population.
To provide important features for speech pathologists to account for when building assessment plans for Indigenous children.
This comprehensive scoping literature review was completed using the Arksey and O'Malley 6-step methodological framework, including the optional consultation exercise, and reported using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) guidelines. To be included, studies needed to have been published since 2000, discuss speech-language assessments and involve a significant proportion of Indigenous participants under 7 years old.
Three features were extracted from 32 studies that discussed First Nations, Métis, Inuit, Native American, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities: using a battery of resources including alternative approaches, ensuring authenticity and cultural relevance, and considering a child's linguistic characteristics.
While there remains a need to adapt according to a specific child's reality, this study provides a guideline for all allied health clinicians when they are building their culturally and linguistically relevant assessment plans.
由于医疗保健和教育中以欧洲为中心的做法,土著儿童可能更容易被误诊为有语言障碍。传统言语病理学评估方法的使用导致了不恰当的障碍识别,进一步给这一弱势群体带来污名。言语病理学家可用的资源很少,这些资源用于检查针对该人群评估的文化和语言相关性。
为言语病理学家在为土著儿童制定评估计划时应考虑的重要特征提供依据。
本全面的范围界定文献综述采用阿克西和奥马利的六步方法框架完成,包括可选的咨询活动,并按照系统评价和Meta分析扩展的范围界定综述的首选报告项目(PRISMA-ScR)指南进行报告。纳入的研究需自2000年以来发表,讨论言语评估,并涉及大量7岁以下的土著参与者。
从32项讨论第一民族、梅蒂斯、因纽特、美洲原住民、原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民社区的研究中提取了三个特征:使用一系列资源,包括替代方法,确保真实性和文化相关性,以及考虑儿童的语言特征。
虽然仍需要根据特定儿童的实际情况进行调整,但本研究为所有健康相关临床医生制定具有文化和语言相关性的评估计划提供了指导方针。