Karney Benjamin R, Zaber Melanie A, Smith Molly G, Mann Samuel J, AlFakhri Marwa, Coe Jessie, Ryan Jamie L, Gadwah-Meaden Catria, Mallory Christy, Sears Brad, Garber Chandra
Rand Health Q. 2024 Sep 25;11(4):1. eCollection 2024 Sep.
Twenty years ago, the United States was divided by heated debates over legalizing marriage for same-sex couples. Those in favor argued that granting same-sex couples access to marriage would strengthen commitment for same-sex couples, extend the financial benefits of marriage to same-sex households, and improve outcomes for children raised by same-sex parents. Those who were opposed argued that granting legal status to marriages between same-sex partners would alter the foundation of marriage and diminish its value for different-sex couples, ultimately harming children by making them less likely to be raised in stable, two-parent families. It has now been 20 years since Massachusetts became the first state to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples in May 2004. The consequences of extending legal recognition to same-sex couples need no longer be a topic of speculation and debate; researchers have had two decades to study the consequences of legalizing marriage for same-sex couples on lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) individuals; their children; and the general public. The broad goal of this study is to document those consequences. The authors pursued this goal in two ways. First, they conducted a comprehensive review of the existing research literature on the effects of legalizing marriage for same-sex couples. Second, they conducted new analyses to evaluate the prediction that rates of marriage, cohabitation, and divorce and attitudes toward marriage would be adversely affected by granting same-sex couples access to legal marriage.
二十年前,美国因同性伴侣婚姻合法化问题展开了激烈辩论,国家因此产生了分歧。支持者认为,赋予同性伴侣婚姻权利将加强同性伴侣之间的承诺,将婚姻的经济利益扩展到同性家庭,并改善由同性父母抚养的孩子的成长结果。反对者则认为,赋予同性伴侣间婚姻的法律地位会改变婚姻的基础,降低其对异性伴侣的价值,最终使孩子不太可能在稳定的双亲家庭中成长,从而伤害到孩子。自2004年5月马萨诸塞州成为首个向同性伴侣颁发结婚证的州以来,已经过去了20年。给予同性伴侣法律认可的后果已不再是一个猜测和辩论的话题;研究人员有二十年的时间来研究同性伴侣婚姻合法化对女同性恋、男同性恋、双性恋和跨性别(LGBT)群体、他们的子女以及普通公众的影响。这项研究的总体目标是记录这些后果。作者通过两种方式来实现这一目标。首先,他们对现有的关于同性伴侣婚姻合法化影响的研究文献进行了全面综述。其次,他们进行了新的分析,以评估同性伴侣获得合法婚姻会对结婚率、同居率、离婚率以及对婚姻的态度产生不利影响这一预测。