Vance Michelle M, Wade Jeannette, Gowdy Grace, Dillon Hannah
Department of Social Work, University of North Carolina at Greensboro, Greensboro, NC, USA.
Human Health Sciences, University of North Carolina at Greensboro, Greensboro, NC, USA.
J Racial Ethn Health Disparities. 2024 Sep 30. doi: 10.1007/s40615-024-02076-z.
The recent shift in Black women's suicide risk calls for a new paradigm focused on unique factors specific to Black womanhood. The Vance-Wade Intersectional Suicide Risk Model (VWISRM) was introduced to contextualize this unexpected spike. According to the VWISRM, for Black women, psychosocial risk factors, gendered racism, and the Strong Black Woman script (SBW) lead to racialized gender stress (RGS) which results in mental health outcomes which are established predictors of suicide-related behaviors.
The National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (Add Health) was used to test for empirical evidence supporting the VWISRM. Our sample consisted of 418 Black female adolescent respondents who fully participated in data collection during Waves 1, 3, and 4. We ran bivariate analyses to examine both (1) what psychosocial factors of Black women are associated with SBW traits, gendered racism, and racialized gendered stress and (2) what mental health outcomes are predicted by SBW traits, gendered racism, and racialized gendered stress.
Our analysis showed having both lower scores on the SBW traits and experiencing gendered racism are associated with a PTSD diagnosis. Specifically, the analysis explained 30% of the variation in PTSD diagnoses among Black women. Having both lower scores on the SBW traits predicted anxiety, PTSD, and contemplating suicide, and having experienced RGS linked to depression anxiety and contemplating suicide. Importantly, there were no moderating effects among SBW traits and RGS on PTSD, anxiety, or suicidality.
Findings highlight important research and clinical implications for Black women's mental health. The Gendered Racism Intersectional Trauma model (GRIT) is introduced to better understand the breadth of mental health outcomes for Black women. Notably, our findings make a new contribution to the scientific inquiry of PTSD in Black women.
近期黑人女性自杀风险的转变需要一种新的范式,该范式应聚焦于黑人女性特有的独特因素。万斯 - 韦德交叉性自杀风险模型(VWISRM)被引入,以解释这一意外的激增现象。根据VWISRM,对于黑人女性而言,心理社会风险因素、性别化种族主义以及“坚强黑人女性”脚本(SBW)会导致种族化性别压力(RGS),进而产生心理健康结果,而这些结果是自杀相关行为的既定预测指标。
利用青少年健康全国纵向研究(Add Health)来检验支持VWISRM的实证证据。我们的样本包括418名黑人女性青少年受访者,她们在第1、3和4轮数据收集期间充分参与。我们进行了双变量分析,以考察:(1)黑人女性的哪些心理社会因素与SBW特质、性别化种族主义和种族化性别压力相关;(2)SBW特质、性别化种族主义和种族化性别压力能预测哪些心理健康结果。
我们的分析表明,SBW特质得分较低且经历性别化种族主义与创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)诊断相关。具体而言,该分析解释了黑人女性PTSD诊断中30%的变异。SBW特质得分较低既预测了焦虑、PTSD和考虑自杀,经历RGS也与抑郁、焦虑和考虑自杀相关。重要的是,SBW特质和RGS对PTSD、焦虑或自杀倾向没有调节作用。
研究结果凸显了对黑人女性心理健康的重要研究和临床意义。引入了性别化种族主义交叉性创伤模型(GRIT),以更好地理解黑人女性心理健康结果的广度。值得注意的是,我们的研究结果为黑人女性PTSD的科学探究做出了新贡献。