Steyn Willem-Johan, Bondo Mukinay C
Department of Family Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pretoria, Pretoria.
S Afr Fam Pract (2004). 2024 Sep 27;66(1):e1-e10. doi: 10.4102/safp.v66i1.5926.
Active euthanasia is a controversial subject both globally and in South Africa. Recent legal cases have kept this topic in the public discourse. Yet, there remains a dearth of quality local research on this issue. This study aimed to explore the views of medical professionals towards active euthanasia to gain a better understanding of this phenomenon in South Africa.
A descriptive-interpretive qualitative research design, using semi-structured in-depth interviews of purposively sampled South African medical professionals, was used to collect the data. The data were analysed using an inductive thematic analysis framework, which included familiarisation, coding, summarising, theme development and thematic review, revision and interpretation.
Four general themes, with sub-themes, were identified and inductively analysed: modern medical practice and euthanasia; the problem of suffering in end-of-life care; euthanasia is complex; palliative care in South Africa is poor. Some themes and sub-themes were common to all participants while other themes underscored more diverse views - often because of religious factors.
Active euthanasia is a complex and nuanced issue. An understanding of the perceptions and attitudes of medical professionals will contribute to the overall discussion of this phenomenon in ethical, legal, social and political spheres in South Africa. This is of utmost importance given the relevance of this topic in South Africa in the 21st century.Contribution: This study highlights the complex nature of active euthanasia in South Africa among medical professionals while providing a greater understanding of its nuances and the strengths and weaknesses of arguments for or against it.
主动安乐死在全球和南非都是一个有争议的话题。最近的法律案件使这个话题一直处于公众讨论之中。然而,关于这个问题的高质量本土研究仍然匮乏。本研究旨在探讨医学专业人员对主动安乐死的看法,以便更好地了解南非的这一现象。
采用描述性解释性定性研究设计,通过对有目的抽样的南非医学专业人员进行半结构化深度访谈来收集数据。使用归纳主题分析框架对数据进行分析,该框架包括熟悉、编码、总结、主题发展以及主题回顾、修订和解释。
确定并归纳分析了四个总体主题及子主题:现代医疗实践与安乐死;临终关怀中的痛苦问题;安乐死很复杂;南非的姑息治疗很差。一些主题和子主题为所有参与者所共有,而其他主题则凸显了更多样化的观点——通常是由于宗教因素。
主动安乐死是一个复杂且微妙的问题。了解医学专业人员的看法和态度将有助于在南非的伦理、法律、社会和政治领域对这一现象进行全面讨论。鉴于这个话题在21世纪南非的相关性,这至关重要。贡献:本研究凸显了南非医学专业人员中主动安乐死的复杂性质,同时更深入地了解了其细微差别以及支持或反对它的论据的优缺点。