Lemaitre Ilona, Jurek Lucie, Souiller Ludovic
Department of Urology, Lyon Sud Hospital, 69495 Oullins-Pierre-Bénite, France; Claude-Bernard University Lyon 1, 69100 Villeurbanne, France.
Children Gender Variance Department, Le Vinatier Hospital, 69678 Bron, France; RESHAPE U1290, University Lyon 1, 69100 Lyon, France.
Encephale. 2025 Jun;51(3):293-299. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2024.05.007. Epub 2024 Oct 5.
The evolution of knowledge and recommendations concerning transgender health has led to various representations, especially for health professionals, that can influence the medical management of transgender individuals. The main objective of this study was to explore the representation of psychiatrists in France regarding gender variance. The secondary objective was to compare these data based on their characteristics.
This is a cross-sectional observational study based on the distribution in April 2022 of a questionnaire to psychiatrists and psychiatric residents in France. The questionnaire was developed after exploring the results of qualitative studies in the scientific literature.
Among 359 respondents, 181 were psychiatric residents and 178 were senior psychiatrists. Ninety percent had already met a transgender person in their professional practice. The representations observed among the respondents were heterogeneous. Most respondents did not consider "transgenderism" a symptom of a psychiatric disorder, and nearly all respondents used the gender and name their patients ask for. About 60% reported insufficient knowledge about "transgenderism", with 86% considering that they had not been trained to adequately support transgender people.
The study reveals that representations, although weakened by a lack of knowledge recognized by psychiatrists, favor a non-pathologizing apprehension of gender variance and recognition of the importance of respecting gender diversity and self-determination. The heterogeneity of representations, as well as the high prevalence of professionals who describe a lack of knowledge, skills, and training, support the need for guidelines and the integration of evidence-based knowledge about gender variance into the psychiatric curriculum.
关于跨性别健康的知识和建议的演变产生了各种观念,尤其是对医疗专业人员而言,这些观念可能会影响对跨性别者的医疗管理。本研究的主要目的是探讨法国精神科医生对性别变异的看法。次要目的是根据他们的特征对这些数据进行比较。
这是一项横断面观察性研究,基于2022年4月向法国的精神科医生和精神科住院医师发放问卷。该问卷是在探索科学文献中的定性研究结果后制定的。
在359名受访者中,181名是精神科住院医师,178名是资深精神科医生。90%的人在其专业实践中已经接触过跨性别者。受访者中观察到的观念存在异质性。大多数受访者不认为“性别认同障碍”是一种精神疾病的症状,几乎所有受访者都使用患者要求的性别和姓名。约60%的人报告对“性别认同障碍”的了解不足,86%的人认为他们没有接受过充分支持跨性别者的培训。
该研究表明,尽管精神科医生认识到知识不足削弱了这些观念,但这些观念有利于对性别变异进行非病理化理解,并认识到尊重性别多样性和自决权的重要性。观念的异质性,以及描述知识、技能和培训不足的专业人员的高比例,支持了制定指南以及将基于证据的性别变异知识纳入精神科课程的必要性。