Research Centre of the University of Montreal Hospital Centre, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Centre d'excellence sur le partenariat avec les patients et le public, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Health Expect. 2024 Oct;27(5):e70054. doi: 10.1111/hex.70054.
The Chronic Care Model (CCM), the Expanded Chronic Care Model (ECCM) and the eHealth Enhanced Chronic Care Model (eCCM) focus on how healthcare teams and eHealth support can offer effective care and relevant solutions for patients facing chronic care conditions. However, they do not consider how patients can help these teams in their work, nor do they promote ways in which patients can help themselves. However, in the last decade, three different models have emerged that can complete our capacity to design and deliver integrated care for people with chronic diseases. In this article, we propose a revised version of the model that integrates the patient perspective and patients' experience-based knowledge. It integrates three different ways of engaging patients that complement the other patient engagement point of view: the experience of care and mediation in healthcare, therapeutic patient education and patient learning pathways, as well as patient-professional partnership.
For each of the three models, we conducted a review of the literature using CINAHL, Medline, OVID, EMBASE PsychINFO, Science Direct and government reports on patient engagement and partnership with their healthcare providers, to integrate the different components of these models into the ECCM and eCCM. The goal is to create a model that better takes into account the experiential knowledge of patients and citizens throughout its different dimensions.
We identified 129 papers based on their framework, design, sample, measures and fit with patient engagement and chronic illness and added our own research when relevant. Integrating the three models provides an opportunity to amplify the role played by the patient perspective in the management of chronic disease. The Expanded Chronic Care Patient-Professional Partnership Model (E2C3PM) is intended to rebalance power relations between healthcare professionals and patients (and their caregivers). This new model is based on recognizing patients' experiential knowledge and their roles as caregivers and as full members of the care team. Integrating patient empowerment into the E2C3PM underscores the importance of coproduction care with patients at the clinical, organizational and system levels within a supportive environment.
Applying this new model should make it possible to better take into account the complexity of chronic diseases, improving the integration not only of care, services and eHealth support but also the various determinants of health and reaching a mutually beneficial settlement among all actors involved.
A patient-researcher contributed to the development of the protocol, the data collection and the preparation and writing of this manuscript.
慢性护理模式(CCM)、扩展慢性护理模式(ECCM)和电子健康增强型慢性护理模式(eCCM)专注于医疗团队和电子健康支持如何为面临慢性护理条件的患者提供有效护理和相关解决方案。然而,它们没有考虑到患者如何帮助这些团队开展工作,也没有促进患者自助的方法。然而,在过去十年中,出现了三种不同的模式,可以完善我们为慢性病患者设计和提供综合护理的能力。在本文中,我们提出了一个经过修订的模型版本,该模型整合了患者视角和患者基于经验的知识。它整合了三种不同的患者参与方式,这些方式补充了其他患者参与观点:医疗保健中的护理体验和调解、治疗性患者教育和患者学习途径,以及患者与专业人员的伙伴关系。
对于每个模型,我们使用 CINAHL、Medline、OVID、EMBASE PsychINFO、Science Direct 和政府关于患者参与及其与医疗保健提供者合作的报告进行了文献综述,将这些模型的不同组件整合到 ECCM 和 eCCM 中。目的是创建一个更好地考虑到不同维度患者和公民经验知识的模型。
我们根据框架、设计、样本、措施和与患者参与和慢性疾病的契合度,确定了 129 篇论文,并在相关时添加了我们自己的研究。整合这三个模型为放大患者视角在慢性病管理中的作用提供了机会。扩展慢性护理患者-专业人员伙伴关系模型(E2C3PM)旨在重新平衡医疗保健专业人员和患者(及其护理人员)之间的权力关系。这个新模型基于认识到患者的经验知识以及他们作为护理人员和作为护理团队的正式成员的角色。在 E2C3PM 中整合患者赋权,强调了在支持性环境中在临床、组织和系统层面与患者共同制定护理的重要性。
应用这个新模型应该能够更好地考虑到慢性病的复杂性,不仅改善护理、服务和电子健康支持的整合,还改善健康的各种决定因素,并在所有相关行为者之间达成互利的解决方案。
一位患者研究人员为该协议的制定、数据收集以及本手稿的准备和撰写做出了贡献。