Department of Philosophy I, University of Granada, Granada 18012, Spain.
University of the Basque Country, Bizkaia 48940, Spain.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 Oct 15;121(42):e2406823121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2406823121. Epub 2024 Oct 8.
In recent decades, many jurisdictions have moved toward legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide, alongside a near-universal increase in public acceptance of medical aid in dying. Here, we draw on a comprehensive quantitative review of current laws on assisted dying, experimental survey evidence, and four decades of time-series data to explore the relationship between these legislative transitions and change in moral attitudes. Our analyses reveal that existing laws on medical aid in dying impose a common set of eligibility restrictions, based on the patient's age, decision-making capacity, prognosis, and the nature of their illness. Fulfillment of these eligibility criteria elevates public moral approval of physician-assisted death, equally in countries with (i.e., Spain) and without (i.e., the United Kingdom) assisted dying laws. Finally, historical records of public attitudes toward euthanasia across numerous countries uncovered anticipatory growth in moral approval leading up to legalization, but no accelerated growth thereafter. Taken together, our findings suggest that the enactment of medical aid in dying laws, and their specific provisions, crystallize patterns in moral intuition.
近几十年来,许多司法管辖区都朝着使安乐死和协助自杀合法化的方向发展,同时公众对医疗辅助死亡的接受度也几乎普遍提高。在这里,我们借鉴了对协助自杀的现行法律的全面定量审查、实验调查证据以及四十年来的时间序列数据,探讨了这些立法转变与道德态度变化之间的关系。我们的分析表明,现有的医疗辅助死亡法规定了一套共同的资格限制,基于患者的年龄、决策能力、预后和疾病性质。满足这些资格标准会同等地提高公众对医生协助死亡的道德认可,无论是在有(例如西班牙)还是没有(例如英国)协助死亡法的国家。最后,对许多国家的安乐死态度的历史记录显示,在合法化之前,道德认可就出现了预期的增长,但之后并没有加速增长。总之,我们的研究结果表明,医疗辅助死亡法的颁布及其具体规定反映了道德直觉的模式。